Since he deleted his blog, and scrubbed it all from wayback, here's an archive of some of the problematic things Ryan has written: https://thewritingsofryankculp.pages.dev/
What's the deal with e-paper and people being bad at have opinions? I personally got the Daylight Computer day one of pre-orders being open. Now they've gone anti-vax. I was about to order this device as well, but then I saw this. I still may order it, but this sucks. Funding this behavior feels ugly.
As another disappointed DC-1 owner (all the more disappointed because despite everything, I still love and use mine, too), I'm not entirely shocked that they went down the crunchy-granola-to-anti-vax rabbit hole. Looking back, their whole branding angle was always a little woowoo. I didn't think much of it, though, until after I'd already bought one and they sent out a user survey asking about my experience with the DC-1. One of the questions was whether the reduced exposure to blue light had enabled me to quit taking antidepressants(?!?).
They certainly won't get more money from me, but if/when my DC-1 ever dies (or when the apps that I need finally stop working on its ridiculously outdated version of Android) I'm not sure what I'll do to replace it. The most promising thing I've seen so far is the TCL NXTPAPER, which has an e-ink-ish mode, and it's a hell of a lot cheaper than anything comparable from Boox/reMarkable/etc.
Kind of putting words in Zambyte's mouth there. "Some opinions are bad" is very different than "all opinions I disagree with are bad"
With the notable exception of moral relativism, every form of ethics classifies at least some action as bad. It's fair, in casual speaking, to refer to opinions counter to that as bad.
Do you truly believe that all opinions are equally good?
Vaccination efficacy is an evidence-based objective fact. Alternatives to believing this fact are either delusions or lying for profit. Referring to anti-vax lies and delusions as "opinions" is far more diplomatic and respectful than those people have earned.
Tough nuts. Part of living in a state is being subject to rules, even if you don't agree with them. This is no different than sovereign citizens, which nearly everyone is perfectly fine publicly ridiculing. Immoral people have decided to popularize the anti-vax position for their own gain. Unlike sovereign citizens, large portions of the west are currently pretending this is a valid, justifiable position to hold.
If one of the responsibilities of the state is to promote health and safety, preventing disease outbreaks is pretty damn high on the list, and the only way to do that is with near-universal vaccination. It really is that simple—people are not entitled to absolute freedom of choice in a society, otherwise we would need no laws, regulations, or enforcement.
This is me. All my kids are vaxxed. Even the weird stuff they'll never get, because an activated immune system is better than one that finds random stuff to be allergic to.
Per the linked article, the concern seems to be vaccine efficacy not libertarian principal.
>Additionally, the company has focused its marketing efforts on parents of autistic children, including through media that platforms vaccine-skeptical views
They also follow other pseudoscience such as:
>Our homes and bedrooms are full of electronic devices – Wi-Fi routers, phones, TVs, smart speakers, not to mention all the wiring in the walls. These devices emit various types of EMFs (radiofrequency radiation, electric and magnetic fields from power currents). If we want to create the best sleep sanctuary, we need to mitigate EMFs in our bedroom.
I think the straw man may be yours. But perhaps that's the government sanctioned and created EMF that's being forced into and through body confusing me.
I'm not seeing anybody preventing them from speaking about their vaccination opinions? I'm just seeing a lot of blowback from the people who see what they say, and call them out on it.
And, I do agree people should not be "forced" to get vaccinated. However, I have no problem with that decision having consequences. Its fine for an employer, or a government or whatever to have vaccination status as a requirement for your job, or going certain places, etc etc.
Again, you're specifically replacing their apparent argument with a separate one. That's a straw man!
Even accepting your, rather than their, argument. Yes, yes, they should be allowed to talk about the things they want. And we should be allowed to call them out on that, say their behavior is harmful to themselves and society, and suggest people not give their businesses patronage. These libertarian principles flow both directions. There isn't even really particularly meaningful debate to be had around the scientific aspect other than to point out their opinions are pretty much not based in sound science and that prior to misinformation spread, it was pretty uncommon for people to take issue with these mandatory vaccinations and childhood vaccination schedules in the same way it's uncommon for people, except those exposed to misinformation, to be upset that our water is often treated and fluoridated.
When they do talk about it (and they will, because they can't seem to shut up about it), and their opinions are factually wrong and cause harm to vulnerable people, then we are also free to call it out and refuse to purchase their products and warn others to do the same.
"Free speech" means the government can't prevent you from saying it. It doesn't mean you won't be ostracized for being an idiot.
Why should we expect people to reconsider their views, let alone reform, when the response is so often extreme public condemnation and ostracism? I'm broadly on what most here would consider the correct side of these social divides, but I find it remarkable how often people on that side respond to misguided perspectives with modern-day witch burnings rather than positive encouragement towards kindness and understanding.
If the goal truly is social progress, perhaps we should spend a little less energy hunting heretics and a little more effort showing empathy. It doesn't matter that the empathy isn't reciprocated. There's value in being the more likeable side to anyone watching from the sidelines.
It's not lost on me that our side often responds to hateful language with our own forms of hatred. Both sides are complicit in allowing these differences to calcify into the worst kind of political tribalism, but I think our side fails every time it turns a teachable moment into a "hateable moment".
Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.
My God. The full trifecta in a single post. There's a lot of unprocessed anger toward the world here:
> "illegals need to get the hell out of our country, or that kids chopping off their d*cks is evil and their parents should be put in prison" · "Muslim refugees are ruining the continent and i made sure to say it loud enough for those around us to hear it" · "isn't it wild how often a Leftist turns out to be a pedophile" · "for women, be prettier and further along in life (married, kids, house)"
And we are somehow supposed to just take you at your word? When it's clear you're putting real effort into making a person look bad?
It's not like this "mirror" is signed with their private key.
Even the "generous" interpretation (that is, quotes real) is an attempt at mob justice: Executing (social death) a person for opinions they might have held at some point in time.
I am starting to understand why Japan's anti-defamation laws famously apply even if the statements are true. Maybe they are ahead.
This person does not need help looking bad; their own words do that just fine.
Which is more likely? That someone made up a bunch of quotes with false attribution, that are entirely consistent with the same person's archived tweets and other materials available from a variety of different sources? Or, that you're so oddly eager to defend this specific person that your first response is "you made that up" despite all the evidence?
Somehow, based on your other comments here, I'm inclined to believe that you would not reach for such vehement denials if you didn't wish it were possible to express those particular opinions while suppressing people's inclination to respond with their own opinions.
It is an odd asymmetry to say that others expressing their positions should "close the tab and move on", while not saying the same about the person being hateful in the first place.
Interesting, how does his politics affect the product/company? Or is it more the sense that you don't want to have relationships with people who have different political beliefs?
He actively denies the validity of trans people. That's a human rights issue, not "politics". If you consider that just politics, then yes I don't want relationships with people who espouse anti-human rights viewpoints.
I guess people who would refer to that as "protecting women's/girl's rights" would then be somewhat more likely to buy from his company?
Also, I would be shocked if a few percent of his company's revenue made it through his salary to his donation pool to the portion of his donation pool that goes to political causes.
Maybe it does, maybe it doesn’t affect the product, but at the end of the day I don’t want to buy something from a person who proudly says my friends are disgusting and calls them awful names.
Go read some of what he's said. He sounds like some teenager you'd encounter playing Call of Duty. Someone with that sort of temperament shouldn't be the CEO of a banana stand and should be forced out by their board.
I agree that someone who speaks immaturely might not be a good leader, and that therefore people might not want to buy things from that company. Is there evidence that his personal style negatively impacts his leadership ability, or that there's any impact on the products as a result?
I'm completely open to the possibility that it would affect the products, but here it seems like people just don't want to do business with someone that is politically unpalatable to them. That's their right, and I appreciate their making that clear here.
Generally speaking, people with impulse control issues don't make the best leaders and don't make the best decisions. Regardless of politics, being an immature jerk online is reasonable evidence of an impulse control issue.
Assuming the people who work with him are aware of what he's said, why would it be so bad for them to work with him that the board would need to remove him from leadership?
My point is that in such small companies, the few people who run them are the company, down to personally owning everything.
I don't mean to be rude, but the big-corpo language about boards, leadership positions, etc is very out of touch with how such businesses actually operate.
I work for a startup of six people. We have a board. If my boss posted even half of what this clown has said online - he’d be gone. And no one would work for him.
I don’t know why people on HN like to split hairs over this stuff. Technically this, actually that, free speech blah blah. This isn’t politics, go read some of the stuff he wrote in his post about Charlie Kirk. There’s a reason he deleted it and then has it removed from the internet archive. It’s embarrassing.
Oh people can decide whatever they want, free association and all that. I was just wondering if there was a product-related reason or if it was just tribal. Sounds like it's just tribal, which again is fine, though not exactly laudable.
For you to say that means that you can't imagine any reason for thinking or doing something other than that a tribe said to.
In fact, it is possible to do something, like finding someones actions objectionble, and like declining to have dealings with them for that reason, without any tribe having told you to do it.
I don't care how great someone's cakes are, if I also know that person kicks a puppy every day on the way to their bake shop, if I have any choice I will just get some other cake somewhere else or maybe even just live without cake altogether if that is the only source of cake in the world and I can survive without cake. It's perfectly "product-related" because there is no single definition of what is and isn't part of the "product".
I understand HN is overrepresented with people that don't understand that, or claim not to anyway.
I'll tell you, there is no "tribe" telling me what to think about comments like this trying to present terms like "product-related" and "just tribal" as probably their favorite word "rational" they love to use any time they actually just want to be assholes but not suffer the stigma of it.
They always think they are House MD or the witch in Into The Woods: "I'm not good, I'm not bad, I'm just right". Yeah ok, how fascinating and novel. No one has ever tried that before. Certainly not every single douchebag teenager in the world since the beginning of time. Certainly we don't have an entire word right in the dictionary just for the concept of attempting to present a refutable biased position as an irrefutable unbiased one by selectively presenting some facts and connecting reasoning that appears rational on it's own, namely "rationalization".
The sea lion in the Wondermark comic was acting completely reasonably. Everyone who uses the term "Sealioning" pejoratively is an authoritarian asshole.
eInk is in fact susceptible to aging, burn-in, and wear.
It's literally a mechanical device (well, I suppose, an electrostatic/fluidic device, but still, it is not solid state...fairly large particles have to physically move/rotate in a liquid layer), one that utilizes a voltage difference of up to 40v, too.
A color iEink screen even more sensitive because now you're not just dealing with flipping particles or making them move closer or further from the surface, you're doing it with four different particles. Similar to how SLC is more durable than TLC, which is more durable than QLC, etc.
True but iirc the particles can only get stuck if you try to squeeze more speed out of the display than you should. Then the particles can slam into the wall and get stuck. Drive safely!
This is the first time I've heard of e-ink experiencing burn-in. I've never had that happen after 10+ years of Kindle usage. Google seems to agree that doesn't happen with e-ink displays. They do experience ghosting, which is cleared upon the next full screen refresh.
I think most people don't realize that the cost for e-ink on a shelf versus paper is still way in the favor of paper, as you said. And that says nothing of the technical challenge that comes with adding that many devices to either an RF or IP network and ensuring that it works with existing, sometimes decades-old pricing systems. Then there's the legal challenges for displaying one price on the shelf but ringing another at the register - with paper, a human can indicate that the price label is updated, but with e-ink, there needs to be some other confirmation of change.
Most Walmarts I've been to in the past year seem to have switched to all eInk displays. I'd love to see a writeup on that rollout.
They're more than just e-ink displays. They also have a very bright green light that flashes when a Wal-Mart picker is nearby so they can find the next item on their list faster.
I've seen a few flashing and was wondering why; that seems like a lot of battery power to waste, but that makes a lot more sense than some kind of status update nobody would ever see.
The cost is not in favor of paper and hasn't been for a decade or so. These devices have been in widespread use in Asia for a long time. Best Buy went to them a few years ago, Walmart is moving to them.
The devices are often optical, with overhead IR transmitters. The fact that you don't know that shows how little you know about the market and thus should not be talking about it.
RF is also used, yes - various protocols ranging from proprietary to bluetooth LE.
Even if only one price per second can be transmitted, that's 3600 items per hour, which means that in 24 hours, 86,400 items can be re-priced. You'd need several employees working non-stop to even hope to hit that rate.
As for the legal challenges they're able to point to logs as well as information on the digital display showing when it was last updated. Also, updates are not necessarily live - they can push out updated pricing info and then activate it at a specific time or via secondary command.
Digital calendars, wall photos that change with the month or seasons or like Antitrust - change after reading the mood in the room with a local AI model on an ESP32 or some other mcu. E-Readers, digital signage (depending on what it is)...
I'm kind of glad in a way that paper prices are still in effect, I think dynamic pricing will be a much more common thing once this goes away and the barrier to do it is much lower.
Depends entirely on the business model of the store. Classic “high/low” pricing models, used by most grocery stores, department stores, and many discount chains require at a minimum weekly repricing of thousands of SKUs (for start of sale and end of sale).
Just a guess, but probably because 8.5x11 / 8.5x14 are American standards, which use different standards for paper sizes than the rest of the world, and there's more of an appetite for e-paper outside of America.
Displaying like a visualizer? Isn't that kind of a waste of the technology? I always understood e-ink to excel at applications that can survive with very low refresh rates
Sheet music - most of the time I see a dual-panel eink device, it's being used to read sheet music off of during a performance, probably with a page-change pedal input too
So make your own with an old monitor panel for a few hundred bucks?
And yeah: there is zero commercial demand for a product like this, it's about as niche as it gets while still existing. No normal person needs an e-ink display this big (because something this size is pretty much useless for anything but a digital poster, which regular TV/monitors can already do better, for cheaper), and the sizes folks do need (e.g. e-readers and passive displays) already have plenty on offer.
But, there are always individuals who want something like this. Not enough to make it a runaway commercial success, but enough to make it a boutique successful-enough-to-stick-around-for-a-while at least.
It's a 30 inch eink screen from a very small company based in the US. This isn't a million unit run from samsung, run by some EVP who buys out the entire factory's output six years in a row.
Everyone talking about the price was LCD are ignoring the fact it has a handwade wooden frame and is being marketed as a boutique, locally assembled art piece.
Get a similar sized IPS for $250 and you can use the rest to cover electricity use for the next 20 years at US avg price. That's assuming 24/7 but you can make it turn off if no one's looking or at night. Not sure what's the use case.
I'm sure you know this and were just offering other options, but the primary reason I like e-ink is for how it looks. How it isn't bright/shiny/lit/in-your-face. It's subdued.
My book-quotes e-ink screens around the house blend in and don't look like screens really and that's exactly how I want them. I wouldn't matter if they were giving away IPS screens, I wouldn't want that all over my house.
One primary use case would be in areas with poor lighting conditions; IPS and other similar displays wind up glare-y or with poor off-axis viewing. These displays at least look like they'd hold up better in a hallway or room with a big window and mixed lighting.
It's a lot to ask for it, and it's too much for my liking... but it's certainly a feature I'd pay a little extra for.
The other would be battery operation — being able to run a device like this for 6 months or a year on battery means I don't have to route a cable up through the wall or in a cable channel, and that's kinda neat too. But again, for the price... oof!
I do want to render a dashboard and/or images and would like to have the eink style of display for it.
Sure i could use a LCD, run ith with less herz than usual and only turn on/off the backlight with a motion sensor but do you know how long i'm waiting for this type of eink display by now? years.
Sold out immediately anyway, I don't think there's much customer pressure driving down prices for these when they make like 400 and sell them to the richest people they can find.
For about same price you can get a Steam Fram- oh wait you can't, Valve also only made 400 of them lmao.
That's the URL I'm looking at. It now says "Only 283 of 475 left in this first batch" and it allows me to add it to my cart and check out. I'm in the U.S.
I feel like e-ink displays are the ideal way to chat with an AI coding agent. Less eye strain, more suited to reading prose. Theoretically, if you chat with it by voice, it doesn't even need high refresh rate. Too bad the technology remains expensive.
This is a new J curve for product pricing that ive never seen before
5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.
If this was closer to $500 it would make sense
Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs
I mean, that's true of like most things. People buy things so that they don't have to make them themselves. This is the fundamental premise of markets.
i could also order a 31.5 inch E Ink Spectra 6 panel
and, if i'm being really dedicated, i could head on down to the beach with a shovel, some carbon, a heat source, a quartz crucible, a uv source, a laser printer, some hobby knives, a liter of sulfuric acid, and a flagrant disrespect for the EPA
then i could grab a couple of notebooks, and bootstrap my own isa, runtime, renderer, and a couple of banks of dip switches.
> Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
I mean.. the product seems to be pretty focused on being an aesthetic, customizable screen and not a utilitarian tech dashboard. In which case, it absolutely needs the wood frame to "fit in" to decor.
I have a second-hand Samsung Frame connected to an old laptop that periodically wakes up, generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame TV via the Samsung Frame’s WebSocket API. It automatically changes the picture every 30 minutes.
The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.
I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.
Not the GP, but I did a similar thing where an eink picture frame displays AI-generated landscapes with the weather being the same as the current weather/time of day as outside.
I just like the variation and didn't need to go source a bunch of actual images of the specific weather patterns.
Thanks for this, I too have an older Frame TV in my living room. Want to explore exporting my calendar and photos to it from a home server via that API!
TRMNL is a cool product, I have the original. This new model looks exactly like what I wanted but certainly not in the budget. Now I have another option!
I purchased a Frame (43”) a few years back. For the specific purpose of being a TV with an Art Mode that plausibly blends in to my living room, it succeeds. Although I do ding it for charging a yearly $75 subscription for access to the updated curated catalogue of art. A few points back again for that sub actually being, in a way, almost worth it. The art is good, is what I’m saying.
Which is a hell of a thing because the smart tv software is so aggressively hostile and awful that it makes me want to give up on using it. The worst experience from moment one on. You can plug it in to an Apple TV and get mostly there but then you need to fight with the remote to get it to reliably switch to art mode.
I do not recommend it, but it’s possible that with some hacking it could be good.
The screen quality is lovely and very good at displaying artwork. It doesn’t look like a TV screen; not exactly like a picture either, but it’s really quite impressive.
The software is appalling in so many ways. Aggressively user-hostile except when it’s upselling at you.
Honestly, I would have the same reservations. Mine's an older model, but Samsung has only become more user-hostile as time has gone on.
That being said, I was able to pretty easily connect my Samsung Frame to the LAN and then block it at the router level from making outbound requests to the internet.
Mine is an old 2022 model so its not OLED - I measured it a while ago (43") and in art mode it was drawing down around ~35-40W on average about 5-6 bucks a month when left on continuously.
I have a use case for this. I want it. I can use it in my daily life. It's what I've been hoping for for years... But this price is crazy. I can't justify owning this at 1.2k. Maybe at 400,id even go for 500, which is a crazy amount of money for a wall display/calendar. But I'd justify the utility at that price.
This looks dope but at that price is just a neat accessory for the wealthy. Is there a feasible route to it being about a tenth the price, like $150? Is it just a scale thing? You can get new dell monitors around that size for $200 or less.
It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.
E-Ink yields are supposedly low at these sizes. But they also have patents, so y’know. There are reflective/transflective LCDs, but they’re not quite the same.
Thank you for posting the relevant facts the company chose to not mention in their long blog post nor its tl;dr header.
To the company: We all understand that ePaper displays are a set of trade-offs, but hiding those specs doesn't make them go away, it just wastes the time of those who want to know what they are.
Slightly relevant but I was just researching a smaller eink-display to place in a hotel room for a client and I discovered the `ReTerminal E1001` - pretty cool if anyone is looking for smaller (7.5") hackable solution with mics and beep for $69.
I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.
I’ve been using a couple of the ReTerminal displays and they’re great. I use the e1004 13” for a family calendar/schedule board. It comes framed and the battery lasts a month or two. It’s the best option I have found that’s not over a thousand dollars.
I have the color and the monochrome one and just know that updates on the color screen take almost 30 seconds of flashing the screen. You don't want one of those in your eyeline. The monochrome are done in <3s.
I have mine set up around the house to display book quotes (rotate once a day) and I quite enjoy them. Though I've been dabbling in BTLE boards instead of ESP32 (what in inside a reTerminal) for more updates and longer battery life.
I recently started playing with a reTerminal E1003, the 10.3 inch monochrome version and I've been very happy with it.
$150 not bad at all for a reasonably high resolution (1404x1872) 10 inch e-ink panel with a touch screen.
Really easy setup for writing custom firmware (I've been using PlatformIO, C and LVGL) and just really solid hardware so far.
The only downside was that it took close to 2 months to get off backorder.
While looking into the available e-ink options I took a look at TRMNL's stuff as well but it turns out the TRMNL founder is a hardcore MAGA racist misogynist and I refuse to give money to such people.
Not quite the same but FWIW I just got a 13.3" SwitchBot Art Frame original and I really like it, I think I'd prob find more use/enjoyment from x2 13" vs a single 31" (SwitchBot have a 31" for around $1,100).
I think they're pretty similar. Same Spectre 6 Panel.
I like my little switchbot, though, and like you I hvae the smaller 13" version. I wish it was more vibrant, though. Not sure if the OP's custom profile thing Lazarus fixes anything with that.
Looks great! Love the wood frame. Would prefer it to be in a different aspect ratio tho, this ratio just says 'screen'.. but perhaps a e.g. 5:7 panel wouldn't be that easy to find?
I am not interested about art nor colour screen but if I could have my grafana monitoring refreshing every 10 sec that would be quite cool. They seem to have other products that are targeting this but I am confused about how the image should go from my browser to the device. You even have to pay extra for the "developer" feature that allows you to access the API (?!).
Whoa, no thanks. I _love_ e-ink and as I was reading I was bracing myself for $300-400, 3-4x that doesn't work for me. I get it's large, I know that large e-ink (even b/w) are not cheap but $1.3K is too rich for my blood.
I was going to buy it as just a nice all-in-one I could flash my own firmware on but not at that price. I guess I'll keep playing with my 7" e-ink screens run by ESP32's or BTLE boards.
Inky Impression has been popular lately. It's ~$275 on its own though. I am making a bird frame running fugleramme[0] and to purchase all of the materials (including RaspberryPi 5, power, frame, etc.) it's about $400 total.
Switchbot Frame [1] is on sale for ~1100, I don't think you're going to find much in a large eInk display like that for less. This looks a lot better and the software sounds better (as a switchbot owner)
I think it's considered cheap in it's class. It looks like a similarly sized InkPoster is 1,700. BLOOMIN8 has a 28.5" one that's on pre-order for $2,200.
Yeah the cheapest spectra 6 31.5” product I can find that is not just the bare panel is the Samsung emdx around $950. $1200 with a nice frame and better software support is reasonable to me.
haven't seen $140 for 13.3” spectra 6, can you share a link? we do already support those models (firmware + core app + oss servers) however, and i don’t like competition.
Why does the "transparent supply chain" list "Overseas" instead of the actual place of origin? The US-sourced parts go as far as saying the city for some entries. It just looks like a ridiculous avoidance of saying China.
I really dislike the muted colors, soft spoken, quiet music, product videos that seem to be everywhere, talking about how "different" they are. Showing someone hand-carving into a piece of wood, talking about "made in the USA", like some third-generation craftsman with a beard and a cap. It all feels like artisanal firewood.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI
I'm sure it's a high quality product, but given that "hacking" a random screen is just a Claude prompt these days, I think it's a hard sale. I think most consumers don't really care about the advantages of eInk versus a cheap display.
This would be a heck of a lot more interesting if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller instead of just putting up with eink's glacial pace of, well, everything (development, improvement, actual image refresh on the panel). There's so much possible with the multipigment screens that's yet to be unlocked with better driver hardware and software.
For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.
Seems it doesn't support wifi or any internet connectivity (zero mention of any of these on any of the sites), which makes it essentially useless. Tough for the price.
Looked interesting, until I saw that you had to pay an extra $20 for unlocking developer mode. At the $1300 price point, nickel-and-diming me for $20 was such a completely unneeded snap in the face, that i closed the purchase tab. Good luck I guess, but i will not be a customer, out of principle.
appreciate the feedback. our perspective is we bend over backwards for the dev community. priority support, 1:1 team chats in our dev-only Discord, manual plugin reviews by hand prior to publication, etc. but if you choose to self host, unnecessary.
Cheap ereaders such as xteink were made popular partly due to the unlocked firmware and custom roms for them. I guess this is a completely different target, but I would think double about it, you just need some guy with too much time and an llm agent to make something that goes popular on YouTube/reddit (...), but for 20$ he might not even want to try it
I think the $20 is a reasonable filter for access to the dev team's energy and time, especially given the alternative of a vastly more expensive moderation and review burden if the floodgates were left open to everyone. HN won't much like it, but that's a normal bias in our community, so don't let us sway you by emotions alone.
Better option is to just provide the dev support for all devs that need something for this device and have it included in the large price. The price splitting makes sense when you have $100 device, but not for $1000+ device.
I would buy one at $1200 if the colors look good/rich in person and if you can change for a different frame. I have a feeling I'm going to be disappointed though - most of the pictures make it look like it has a bit of a washed out appearance.
At 31.5” and 1440p resolution this display has a PPI of 94. So it’s probably best viewed from a distance. I’m waiting for my 13” version (~150 PPI) to see if it makes sense to go bigger.
To all those decrying that this device is USD 1200 - you should look at the Samsung EM32DX and Samsung EM32DX-A displays. They are likely the same panel in a (flimsy) digital signage frame, and the EM32DX has gone for EUR 500 recently. Both devices started at EUR 1200 as well, so I guess that is just the cost for the eInk panels.
In the same vein is using the word "corporate" imagining that it conveys some meaning other than the user not understanding that one person corporations are a thing.
It conveys that the presentation of a business is different than a person, if the person is at all professional and adult. The number of employees is irrelevant.
A single person still wears different clothes and speaks with different language when acting as or on behalf of a business, than when at home in their pajamas passing a bong with their friends.
A business, like anyone, can certainly decide that it wants to portray this exact crafted image intentionally (rather than as the result of being dipshits) but equally potential cutomers or vendors can percieve that image however they want and make whatever judgements and conclusions about the business operators they want from it.
Anyway the single-personhood has no bearing. You're accusing someone of something only you did.
You've argued against the straw man you've created that "corporate" and "business" are synonyms - the same as the original commenter. Just say "business" if that's what is meant instead of tarting it up in some imagined way by writing "corporate". Unless you actually wouldn't object to the presentation style if the business was, instead, a partnership.
234 comments:
I was a huge fan of Trmnl when they first launched. I even convinced my friends to buy a few.
Then the QA started to go down or the devices wouldn’t ship on time. On top of that, Ryan’s politics were a big turnoff.
I would not buy another device from this company.
Since he deleted his blog, and scrubbed it all from wayback, here's an archive of some of the problematic things Ryan has written: https://thewritingsofryankculp.pages.dev/
Also https://www.reddit.com/r/ATPfm/comments/1r70awh/why_did_marc... .
That's outright unhinged.
YIKES.
This is a better summary of what I wanted to say without getting reported here. I am truly appalled
Wow. I thought TRMNL was cool; no way I'm buying any now.
What's the deal with e-paper and people being bad at have opinions? I personally got the Daylight Computer day one of pre-orders being open. Now they've gone anti-vax. I was about to order this device as well, but then I saw this. I still may order it, but this sucks. Funding this behavior feels ugly.
Edit since this is being downvoted: https://casewrites.leaflet.pub/3mt5ap4xpxs2a?utm_source=blue...
This is not my blog post, but I am writing this comment on my DC-1.
As another disappointed DC-1 owner (all the more disappointed because despite everything, I still love and use mine, too), I'm not entirely shocked that they went down the crunchy-granola-to-anti-vax rabbit hole. Looking back, their whole branding angle was always a little woowoo. I didn't think much of it, though, until after I'd already bought one and they sent out a user survey asking about my experience with the DC-1. One of the questions was whether the reduced exposure to blue light had enabled me to quit taking antidepressants(?!?).
They certainly won't get more money from me, but if/when my DC-1 ever dies (or when the apps that I need finally stop working on its ridiculously outdated version of Android) I'm not sure what I'll do to replace it. The most promising thing I've seen so far is the TCL NXTPAPER, which has an e-ink-ish mode, and it's a hell of a lot cheaper than anything comparable from Boox/reMarkable/etc.
> bad opinions
"You disagree with me so you're opinions are BAD!" - Zambyte
Kind of putting words in Zambyte's mouth there. "Some opinions are bad" is very different than "all opinions I disagree with are bad"
With the notable exception of moral relativism, every form of ethics classifies at least some action as bad. It's fair, in casual speaking, to refer to opinions counter to that as bad.
Do you truly believe that all opinions are equally good?
Vaccination efficacy is an evidence-based objective fact. Alternatives to believing this fact are either delusions or lying for profit. Referring to anti-vax lies and delusions as "opinions" is far more diplomatic and respectful than those people have earned.
>Vaccination efficacy
Is typically a strawman.
There's many reasons people could be "anti-vaxxers". Doubting vaccination efficacy is only one of them.
Many argue that, irrespective of efficacy, nobody should be FORCED to inject anything into their bodies.
To them, it might be the last barrier that the state should never be allowed to cross.
Tough nuts. Part of living in a state is being subject to rules, even if you don't agree with them. This is no different than sovereign citizens, which nearly everyone is perfectly fine publicly ridiculing. Immoral people have decided to popularize the anti-vax position for their own gain. Unlike sovereign citizens, large portions of the west are currently pretending this is a valid, justifiable position to hold.
If one of the responsibilities of the state is to promote health and safety, preventing disease outbreaks is pretty damn high on the list, and the only way to do that is with near-universal vaccination. It really is that simple—people are not entitled to absolute freedom of choice in a society, otherwise we would need no laws, regulations, or enforcement.
This is me. All my kids are vaxxed. Even the weird stuff they'll never get, because an activated immune system is better than one that finds random stuff to be allergic to.
However, my body, my choice.
Per the linked article, the concern seems to be vaccine efficacy not libertarian principal.
>Additionally, the company has focused its marketing efforts on parents of autistic children, including through media that platforms vaccine-skeptical views
They also follow other pseudoscience such as:
>Our homes and bedrooms are full of electronic devices – Wi-Fi routers, phones, TVs, smart speakers, not to mention all the wiring in the walls. These devices emit various types of EMFs (radiofrequency radiation, electric and magnetic fields from power currents). If we want to create the best sleep sanctuary, we need to mitigate EMFs in our bedroom.
I think the straw man may be yours. But perhaps that's the government sanctioned and created EMF that's being forced into and through body confusing me.
>Per the linked article, the concern seems to be vaccine efficacy not libertarian principal.
I don't think it does even matter.
Following the libertarian principal: Whatever the reason, if they don't want to get vaccinated, they shouldn't be forced to.
And if they want to talk about it, they should be free to do so.
I'm not seeing anybody preventing them from speaking about their vaccination opinions? I'm just seeing a lot of blowback from the people who see what they say, and call them out on it.
And, I do agree people should not be "forced" to get vaccinated. However, I have no problem with that decision having consequences. Its fine for an employer, or a government or whatever to have vaccination status as a requirement for your job, or going certain places, etc etc.
> if they don't want to get vaccinated, they shouldn't be forced to
When has anyone made this argument? We're the ones being forced to deal with disease-ridden plague peddlers.
Again, you're specifically replacing their apparent argument with a separate one. That's a straw man!
Even accepting your, rather than their, argument. Yes, yes, they should be allowed to talk about the things they want. And we should be allowed to call them out on that, say their behavior is harmful to themselves and society, and suggest people not give their businesses patronage. These libertarian principles flow both directions. There isn't even really particularly meaningful debate to be had around the scientific aspect other than to point out their opinions are pretty much not based in sound science and that prior to misinformation spread, it was pretty uncommon for people to take issue with these mandatory vaccinations and childhood vaccination schedules in the same way it's uncommon for people, except those exposed to misinformation, to be upset that our water is often treated and fluoridated.
When they do talk about it (and they will, because they can't seem to shut up about it), and their opinions are factually wrong and cause harm to vulnerable people, then we are also free to call it out and refuse to purchase their products and warn others to do the same.
"Free speech" means the government can't prevent you from saying it. It doesn't mean you won't be ostracized for being an idiot.
Ah, good to know.
I'm glad I did not buy one of these devices.
Annoyingly I literally just bought one. I haven’t even taken it out of the packaging yet. I wish I had seen these posts 1 week ago.
You can return it.
Why should we expect people to reconsider their views, let alone reform, when the response is so often extreme public condemnation and ostracism? I'm broadly on what most here would consider the correct side of these social divides, but I find it remarkable how often people on that side respond to misguided perspectives with modern-day witch burnings rather than positive encouragement towards kindness and understanding.
If the goal truly is social progress, perhaps we should spend a little less energy hunting heretics and a little more effort showing empathy. It doesn't matter that the empathy isn't reciprocated. There's value in being the more likeable side to anyone watching from the sidelines.
It's not lost on me that our side often responds to hateful language with our own forms of hatred. Both sides are complicit in allowing these differences to calcify into the worst kind of political tribalism, but I think our side fails every time it turns a teachable moment into a "hateable moment".
Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.
Thanks for the headsup!
I literally just pre-ordered one of these things and now I have to cancel, what a loser.
What is your reason for cancelling?
Read up ^^
My God. The full trifecta in a single post. There's a lot of unprocessed anger toward the world here:
> "illegals need to get the hell out of our country, or that kids chopping off their d*cks is evil and their parents should be put in prison" · "Muslim refugees are ruining the continent and i made sure to say it loud enough for those around us to hear it" · "isn't it wild how often a Leftist turns out to be a pedophile" · "for women, be prettier and further along in life (married, kids, house)"
Hah you know it's bad when there's a site dedicated to the archival of it..
Another open-source, hackable, open-hardware project, another puritanical crusade against the founder's political beliefs.
I really wish there was a HN without all the whiny pearl clutching.
i love the tags on the quotes in case you weren't sure what made them offensive
It is LLMs. They love adding as many stats/figures/numbers onto web pages as possible.
(hilarious)
"problematic" == he doesn't agree with my politics.
You're right, "problematic" is too weak, when he thinks some of my friends shouldn't be allowed to exist. I was being polite.
How do you know what he thinks? None of the quotes on that page suggest killing anyone.
He openly disrespects people calling then letter people, trannies, etc. that’s not politics. It’s a jerk.
Evil would be a better description of his views than any particular political affiliation
Have you read what he wrote? The man is a transphobe.
I've got a feeling they are too
Lol that isn't political. That's being a hateful person. Big difference.
And we are somehow supposed to just take you at your word? When it's clear you're putting real effort into making a person look bad?
It's not like this "mirror" is signed with their private key.
Even the "generous" interpretation (that is, quotes real) is an attempt at mob justice: Executing (social death) a person for opinions they might have held at some point in time.
I am starting to understand why Japan's anti-defamation laws famously apply even if the statements are true. Maybe they are ahead.
This person does not need help looking bad; their own words do that just fine.
Which is more likely? That someone made up a bunch of quotes with false attribution, that are entirely consistent with the same person's archived tweets and other materials available from a variety of different sources? Or, that you're so oddly eager to defend this specific person that your first response is "you made that up" despite all the evidence?
Somehow, based on your other comments here, I'm inclined to believe that you would not reach for such vehement denials if you didn't wish it were possible to express those particular opinions while suppressing people's inclination to respond with their own opinions.
It is an odd asymmetry to say that others expressing their positions should "close the tab and move on", while not saying the same about the person being hateful in the first place.
I was about to pull the trigger, thank goodness I saw this and looked into it.
What a horrible person
Interesting, how does his politics affect the product/company? Or is it more the sense that you don't want to have relationships with people who have different political beliefs?
He actively denies the validity of trans people. That's a human rights issue, not "politics". If you consider that just politics, then yes I don't want relationships with people who espouse anti-human rights viewpoints.
Right. A dollar given to his company is a few cents that go towards a donation to a politican that promises to suppress trans rights. No thanks.
> suppress trans rights
I guess people who would refer to that as "protecting women's/girl's rights" would then be somewhat more likely to buy from his company?
Also, I would be shocked if a few percent of his company's revenue made it through his salary to his donation pool to the portion of his donation pool that goes to political causes.
Money is power. I have the power to give my money to people I want to support. I actually carry a responsibility to do so.
Same here. It's the reason I won't buy a Tesla.
Rather depends on the political beliefs though doesn't it?.
There are people who hold views so antithetical to mine that I feel no compulsion to reward them with my money.
Maybe it does, maybe it doesn’t affect the product, but at the end of the day I don’t want to buy something from a person who proudly says my friends are disgusting and calls them awful names.
Go read some of what he's said. He sounds like some teenager you'd encounter playing Call of Duty. Someone with that sort of temperament shouldn't be the CEO of a banana stand and should be forced out by their board.
I agree that someone who speaks immaturely might not be a good leader, and that therefore people might not want to buy things from that company. Is there evidence that his personal style negatively impacts his leadership ability, or that there's any impact on the products as a result?
I'm completely open to the possibility that it would affect the products, but here it seems like people just don't want to do business with someone that is politically unpalatable to them. That's their right, and I appreciate their making that clear here.
Generally speaking, people with impulse control issues don't make the best leaders and don't make the best decisions. Regardless of politics, being an immature jerk online is reasonable evidence of an impulse control issue.
Board? It is a small company with 25 people, not Apple.
Ok? My point is - someone like that shouldn't be in a position of leadership, can't imagine what its like to work with him.
Assuming the people who work with him are aware of what he's said, why would it be so bad for them to work with him that the board would need to remove him from leadership?
My point is that in such small companies, the few people who run them are the company, down to personally owning everything.
I don't mean to be rude, but the big-corpo language about boards, leadership positions, etc is very out of touch with how such businesses actually operate.
I work for a startup of six people. We have a board. If my boss posted even half of what this clown has said online - he’d be gone. And no one would work for him.
I don’t know why people on HN like to split hairs over this stuff. Technically this, actually that, free speech blah blah. This isn’t politics, go read some of the stuff he wrote in his post about Charlie Kirk. There’s a reason he deleted it and then has it removed from the internet archive. It’s embarrassing.
what “political belief” is loudly using slurs associated with? Is that primarily a “political belief”?
be honest with yourself
Interesting, how is it unreasonable to reap what you sow?
Oh people can decide whatever they want, free association and all that. I was just wondering if there was a product-related reason or if it was just tribal. Sounds like it's just tribal, which again is fine, though not exactly laudable.
For you to say that means that you can't imagine any reason for thinking or doing something other than that a tribe said to.
In fact, it is possible to do something, like finding someones actions objectionble, and like declining to have dealings with them for that reason, without any tribe having told you to do it.
I don't care how great someone's cakes are, if I also know that person kicks a puppy every day on the way to their bake shop, if I have any choice I will just get some other cake somewhere else or maybe even just live without cake altogether if that is the only source of cake in the world and I can survive without cake. It's perfectly "product-related" because there is no single definition of what is and isn't part of the "product".
I understand HN is overrepresented with people that don't understand that, or claim not to anyway.
I'll tell you, there is no "tribe" telling me what to think about comments like this trying to present terms like "product-related" and "just tribal" as probably their favorite word "rational" they love to use any time they actually just want to be assholes but not suffer the stigma of it.
They always think they are House MD or the witch in Into The Woods: "I'm not good, I'm not bad, I'm just right". Yeah ok, how fascinating and novel. No one has ever tried that before. Certainly not every single douchebag teenager in the world since the beginning of time. Certainly we don't have an entire word right in the dictionary just for the concept of attempting to present a refutable biased position as an irrefutable unbiased one by selectively presenting some facts and connecting reasoning that appears rational on it's own, namely "rationalization".
You seem to have misread my comment. I didn't say anything about a tribe telling anyone to do anything.
If by late 2026 you don’t understand that this is called sealioning and cannot be given the benefit of the doubt, I don’t know what to tell you.
The sea lion in the Wondermark comic was acting completely reasonably. Everyone who uses the term "Sealioning" pejoratively is an authoritarian asshole.
Yada yada 1.2k :(
Man how long and often do I need to get my hopes up?
You can't tell me that the company having the patent is so bad in making it cheaper and better so that the mass market would kick in?
Or is there 0 mass market for things like that?
Or is it really that expensive to make them bigger?
Lets see who wins in a few years: The price going down or my wallet
There's really not much mass market outside of e-readers already. e ink monitor sized panels are a niche of a niche.
No mass market at $400/sqft, but there might be all kinds up applications at $25/sqft like tvs.
Bit of a chicken and egg. TV panels got so cheap because of the massive volume used.
Can this eInk display drive at 30-60fps continually for months without damage?
30fps? No.
Continually for months is fine though. In fact it can passively display the same image forever without power or burn-in.
tbf there were news that 30fps has been achieved just fine
dunno about longevity
eInk is in fact susceptible to aging, burn-in, and wear.
It's literally a mechanical device (well, I suppose, an electrostatic/fluidic device, but still, it is not solid state...fairly large particles have to physically move/rotate in a liquid layer), one that utilizes a voltage difference of up to 40v, too.
A color iEink screen even more sensitive because now you're not just dealing with flipping particles or making them move closer or further from the surface, you're doing it with four different particles. Similar to how SLC is more durable than TLC, which is more durable than QLC, etc.
True but iirc the particles can only get stuck if you try to squeeze more speed out of the display than you should. Then the particles can slam into the wall and get stuck. Drive safely!
This is the first time I've heard of e-ink experiencing burn-in. I've never had that happen after 10+ years of Kindle usage. Google seems to agree that doesn't happen with e-ink displays. They do experience ghosting, which is cleared upon the next full screen refresh.
Seems unlikely. Commercial grade digital signage displays are better suited to that.
That is not the idea of an eInk display. It is not primarily meant for animations.
Not true. Every price tag on a shelf should be an e-ink display by now. But it's still rare since they are price prohibitive for most retailers.
There are lots of these use cases where e-ink displays would be perfect, but cannot be adopted.
I think most people don't realize that the cost for e-ink on a shelf versus paper is still way in the favor of paper, as you said. And that says nothing of the technical challenge that comes with adding that many devices to either an RF or IP network and ensuring that it works with existing, sometimes decades-old pricing systems. Then there's the legal challenges for displaying one price on the shelf but ringing another at the register - with paper, a human can indicate that the price label is updated, but with e-ink, there needs to be some other confirmation of change.
In some places, the calculation is clearly going in favor of E-Ink tags. I assume the lower management effort you mentioned will be a part of that.
Most Walmarts I've been to in the past year seem to have switched to all eInk displays. I'd love to see a writeup on that rollout.
Several supermarkets here (UK) have mostly switched over, including those traditionally thought of as bargain basement establishments.
Most Walmarts I've been to in the past year seem to have switched to all eInk displays. I'd love to see a writeup on that rollout.
They're more than just e-ink displays. They also have a very bright green light that flashes when a Wal-Mart picker is nearby so they can find the next item on their list faster.
Ah THAT'S what that's for. TIL.
I've seen a few flashing and was wondering why; that seems like a lot of battery power to waste, but that makes a lot more sense than some kind of status update nobody would ever see.
That makes sense why they’d bother as the prices don’t change THAT rapidly
The cost is not in favor of paper and hasn't been for a decade or so. These devices have been in widespread use in Asia for a long time. Best Buy went to them a few years ago, Walmart is moving to them.
The devices are often optical, with overhead IR transmitters. The fact that you don't know that shows how little you know about the market and thus should not be talking about it.
RF is also used, yes - various protocols ranging from proprietary to bluetooth LE.
Even if only one price per second can be transmitted, that's 3600 items per hour, which means that in 24 hours, 86,400 items can be re-priced. You'd need several employees working non-stop to even hope to hit that rate.
As for the legal challenges they're able to point to logs as well as information on the digital display showing when it was last updated. Also, updates are not necessarily live - they can push out updated pricing info and then activate it at a specific time or via secondary command.
These price tags are everywhere in Scandinavian shops https://www.pricer.com/
In German supermarkets, they basically are everywhere. Two colored (black and red), of various sizes. The do look like paper so hardly anyone notices.
Digital calendars, wall photos that change with the month or seasons or like Antitrust - change after reading the mood in the room with a local AI model on an ESP32 or some other mcu. E-Readers, digital signage (depending on what it is)...
E-ink price tags are everywhere in Canada, even at discount-type grocery stores that don't yet have other "innovations" like self check out.
I'm kind of glad in a way that paper prices are still in effect, I think dynamic pricing will be a much more common thing once this goes away and the barrier to do it is much lower.
> Every price tag on a shelf should be an e-ink display by now.
This is the case in multiple chains in the UK.
Prices should be stable enough that the costs of updating paper labels isn't prohibitive.
Depends entirely on the business model of the store. Classic “high/low” pricing models, used by most grocery stores, department stores, and many discount chains require at a minimum weekly repricing of thousands of SKUs (for start of sale and end of sale).
Wal-Mart is switching every price tag to e-ink by the end of 2026.
very small ones seems like the best use case, sure
In Hungary, you know, the poorer corner of the EU, most major supermarkets, discount franchises carry eink price tags.
I absolutely do not agree with that.
Advertising?
People like bright colors for advertising and tv panels are pretty cheap now. I can't see a huge demand for eink specifically there
Why is all epaper in weird sizes? Why isn't there an 8.5x11 or 8.5x14 sized display? Or even a notecard sized 3.5x5?
Just a guess, but probably because 8.5x11 / 8.5x14 are American standards, which use different standards for paper sizes than the rest of the world, and there's more of an appetite for e-paper outside of America.
I'm looking forward to the day e-ink is so cheap I can paper my walls with it.
Until then I'll just have to be satisfied buying every Kobo I find at my local thrift shop (3 so far).
For perspective, a 24" CRT was much more than that 20 years ago, even before adjusting for inflation.
Just niche markets. There's a kickstarter for a two-panel eInk display that was shown displaying music.
I'd like that, though not at the price point they wanted to launch at ($1200, I think)
Displaying like a visualizer? Isn't that kind of a waste of the technology? I always understood e-ink to excel at applications that can survive with very low refresh rates
Sheet music - most of the time I see a dual-panel eink device, it's being used to read sheet music off of during a performance, probably with a page-change pedal input too
So make your own with an old monitor panel for a few hundred bucks?
And yeah: there is zero commercial demand for a product like this, it's about as niche as it gets while still existing. No normal person needs an e-ink display this big (because something this size is pretty much useless for anything but a digital poster, which regular TV/monitors can already do better, for cheaper), and the sizes folks do need (e.g. e-readers and passive displays) already have plenty on offer.
But, there are always individuals who want something like this. Not enough to make it a runaway commercial success, but enough to make it a boutique successful-enough-to-stick-around-for-a-while at least.
It's a 30 inch eink screen from a very small company based in the US. This isn't a million unit run from samsung, run by some EVP who buys out the entire factory's output six years in a row.
Everyone talking about the price was LCD are ignoring the fact it has a handwade wooden frame and is being marketed as a boutique, locally assembled art piece.
Get a similar sized IPS for $250 and you can use the rest to cover electricity use for the next 20 years at US avg price. That's assuming 24/7 but you can make it turn off if no one's looking or at night. Not sure what's the use case.
I'm sure you know this and were just offering other options, but the primary reason I like e-ink is for how it looks. How it isn't bright/shiny/lit/in-your-face. It's subdued.
My book-quotes e-ink screens around the house blend in and don't look like screens really and that's exactly how I want them. I wouldn't matter if they were giving away IPS screens, I wouldn't want that all over my house.
One primary use case would be in areas with poor lighting conditions; IPS and other similar displays wind up glare-y or with poor off-axis viewing. These displays at least look like they'd hold up better in a hallway or room with a big window and mixed lighting.
It's a lot to ask for it, and it's too much for my liking... but it's certainly a feature I'd pay a little extra for.
The other would be battery operation — being able to run a device like this for 6 months or a year on battery means I don't have to route a cable up through the wall or in a cable channel, and that's kinda neat too. But again, for the price... oof!
I do want to render a dashboard and/or images and would like to have the eink style of display for it.
Sure i could use a LCD, run ith with less herz than usual and only turn on/off the backlight with a motion sensor but do you know how long i'm waiting for this type of eink display by now? years.
It's a fairly reasonable price compared to the competition. E.g. this looks like it uses the same display but is much more expensive: https://inkposter.com/products/inkposter-affresco-31-5
It's a niche product and e-ink has a monopoly on the technology. They can basically price it how they like.
I agree it would be really nice if it was like half the price though. Hard to justify at £1k.
Seems like the other guys have partnered with companies like pocketbook and in the case of the really high end device: Pininfarina.
the other display a few hundred dollars more, but shipping is 2-10 days instead of "estimated early 2027"
> a few hundred dollars more
?? It's 1.75x the price...
Sold out immediately anyway, I don't think there's much customer pressure driving down prices for these when they make like 400 and sell them to the richest people they can find.
For about same price you can get a Steam Fram- oh wait you can't, Valve also only made 400 of them lmao.
I’ve been wanting something like this for a while. $1200 is more than I’m ready to pay for it but it’s cool that this exists!
I really wish they were more affordable, they are so cool, can't wait to put a bunch of eink displays everywhere
Well it's sold out so I guess they didn't set price high enough.
False? "Only 351 of 475 left in this first batch"
At the time of writing my original comment and now this url [1] says sold out, where are you seeing your info?
1. https://shop.trmnl.com/products/frame
That's the URL I'm looking at. It now says "Only 283 of 475 left in this first batch" and it allows me to add it to my cart and check out. I'm in the U.S.
There's an annotation below the stock counter that says "Outside the USA, Canada, Australia, or Mexico? We're not sold out. Order here."
I feel like e-ink displays are the ideal way to chat with an AI coding agent. Less eye strain, more suited to reading prose. Theoretically, if you chat with it by voice, it doesn't even need high refresh rate. Too bad the technology remains expensive.
This is a new J curve for product pricing that ive never seen before
5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.
If this was closer to $500 it would make sense
Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs
I think the wood is delightful. It's very tasteful and I generally prefer natural materials whenever possible.
I think the point is, you can do it yourself or hire a carpenter if you really care about that.
I mean, that's true of like most things. People buy things so that they don't have to make them themselves. This is the fundamental premise of markets.
i could also order a 31.5 inch E Ink Spectra 6 panel
and, if i'm being really dedicated, i could head on down to the beach with a shovel, some carbon, a heat source, a quartz crucible, a uv source, a laser printer, some hobby knives, a liter of sulfuric acid, and a flagrant disrespect for the EPA
then i could grab a couple of notebooks, and bootstrap my own isa, runtime, renderer, and a couple of banks of dip switches.
you know... if you really care about that
the wood frame is made in America, but the display itself is made in China and can be sourced from there, I believe.
waiting for some noname brands with this exact same product show up on Amazon soon
> Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
I mean.. the product seems to be pretty focused on being an aesthetic, customizable screen and not a utilitarian tech dashboard. In which case, it absolutely needs the wood frame to "fit in" to decor.
I have a second-hand Samsung Frame connected to an old laptop that periodically wakes up, generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame TV via the Samsung Frame’s WebSocket API. It automatically changes the picture every 30 minutes.
The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.
I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.
https://imgpb.com/EZmRX
> generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame
I don't mean this in a rude way, but you display AI images in your home as art? Do you just like the AI images better than art?
I'm trying to understand what this actually means.
Looks like that’s the case, the blog linked in the original post describes their image generation setup.
Not the GP, but I did a similar thing where an eink picture frame displays AI-generated landscapes with the weather being the same as the current weather/time of day as outside.
I just like the variation and didn't need to go source a bunch of actual images of the specific weather patterns.
Thanks for this, I too have an older Frame TV in my living room. Want to explore exporting my calendar and photos to it from a home server via that API!
TRMNL is a cool product, I have the original. This new model looks exactly like what I wanted but certainly not in the budget. Now I have another option!
Are Samsung Frames (or similar) worth it? It's hard to justify when some spyware TV can go on a wall and be $400
I purchased a Frame (43”) a few years back. For the specific purpose of being a TV with an Art Mode that plausibly blends in to my living room, it succeeds. Although I do ding it for charging a yearly $75 subscription for access to the updated curated catalogue of art. A few points back again for that sub actually being, in a way, almost worth it. The art is good, is what I’m saying.
Which is a hell of a thing because the smart tv software is so aggressively hostile and awful that it makes me want to give up on using it. The worst experience from moment one on. You can plug it in to an Apple TV and get mostly there but then you need to fight with the remote to get it to reliably switch to art mode.
I do not recommend it, but it’s possible that with some hacking it could be good.
The screen quality is lovely and very good at displaying artwork. It doesn’t look like a TV screen; not exactly like a picture either, but it’s really quite impressive.
The software is appalling in so many ways. Aggressively user-hostile except when it’s upselling at you.
Honestly, I would have the same reservations. Mine's an older model, but Samsung has only become more user-hostile as time has gone on.
That being said, I was able to pretty easily connect my Samsung Frame to the LAN and then block it at the router level from making outbound requests to the internet.
looks awesome, thanks for sharing.
But is oled right? So it constantly sips power right?
Mine is an old 2022 model so its not OLED - I measured it a while ago (43") and in art mode it was drawing down around ~35-40W on average about 5-6 bucks a month when left on continuously.
I have a use case for this. I want it. I can use it in my daily life. It's what I've been hoping for for years... But this price is crazy. I can't justify owning this at 1.2k. Maybe at 400,id even go for 500, which is a crazy amount of money for a wall display/calendar. But I'd justify the utility at that price.
https://paperlesspaper.de/en.
Is a lot smaller, but the one on my wall works surprisingly well.
Seems to be EU only? Would love if they shipped to US.
What I need is the big screen. I use a whiteboard that is roughly the 30" size
This looks dope but at that price is just a neat accessory for the wealthy. Is there a feasible route to it being about a tenth the price, like $150? Is it just a scale thing? You can get new dell monitors around that size for $200 or less.
It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.
E-Ink yields are supposedly low at these sizes. But they also have patents, so y’know. There are reflective/transflective LCDs, but they’re not quite the same.
This is basically only usable as a picture frame for paintings and drawings and/or some text; photos don’t look too well.
Full frame updates take 20-30 seconds.
Content needs to be dithered to the six fixed colors (no gradations) at the already fairly low 93 PPI.
Contrast is something like 25:1.
It’s spectra-6, presumably. They’re the same refresh speed, resolution and contrast ratio at any size.
It’s a good display tech. Don’t expect any end product to be particularly differentiated in terms of image quality though.
Thank you for posting the relevant facts the company chose to not mention in their long blog post nor its tl;dr header.
To the company: We all understand that ePaper displays are a set of trade-offs, but hiding those specs doesn't make them go away, it just wastes the time of those who want to know what they are.
Slightly relevant but I was just researching a smaller eink-display to place in a hotel room for a client and I discovered the `ReTerminal E1001` - pretty cool if anyone is looking for smaller (7.5") hackable solution with mics and beep for $69.
I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.
I’ve been using a couple of the ReTerminal displays and they’re great. I use the e1004 13” for a family calendar/schedule board. It comes framed and the battery lasts a month or two. It’s the best option I have found that’s not over a thousand dollars.
Looks like they have a color version too for ≈$100 (reTerminal E1002) and a larger 13.3" color display for $280 (reTerminal E1004)
I have the color and the monochrome one and just know that updates on the color screen take almost 30 seconds of flashing the screen. You don't want one of those in your eyeline. The monochrome are done in <3s.
I have mine set up around the house to display book quotes (rotate once a day) and I quite enjoy them. Though I've been dabbling in BTLE boards instead of ESP32 (what in inside a reTerminal) for more updates and longer battery life.
Can the monochrome ones do partial screen updates, like 8x12 in half a second?
I recently started playing with a reTerminal E1003, the 10.3 inch monochrome version and I've been very happy with it.
$150 not bad at all for a reasonably high resolution (1404x1872) 10 inch e-ink panel with a touch screen.
Really easy setup for writing custom firmware (I've been using PlatformIO, C and LVGL) and just really solid hardware so far.
The only downside was that it took close to 2 months to get off backorder.
While looking into the available e-ink options I took a look at TRMNL's stuff as well but it turns out the TRMNL founder is a hardcore MAGA racist misogynist and I refuse to give money to such people.
Oh man I was really hoping it was using this tech under the hood: https://www.crowdsupply.com/modos-tech/modos-flow
Not quite the same but FWIW I just got a 13.3" SwitchBot Art Frame original and I really like it, I think I'd prob find more use/enjoyment from x2 13" vs a single 31" (SwitchBot have a 31" for around $1,100).
I think they're pretty similar. Same Spectre 6 Panel.
I like my little switchbot, though, and like you I hvae the smaller 13" version. I wish it was more vibrant, though. Not sure if the OP's custom profile thing Lazarus fixes anything with that.
Looks great! Love the wood frame. Would prefer it to be in a different aspect ratio tho, this ratio just says 'screen'.. but perhaps a e.g. 5:7 panel wouldn't be that easy to find?
I am not interested about art nor colour screen but if I could have my grafana monitoring refreshing every 10 sec that would be quite cool. They seem to have other products that are targeting this but I am confused about how the image should go from my browser to the device. You even have to pay extra for the "developer" feature that allows you to access the API (?!).
Self-charging options?
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inkanva/inkanva
Such as:
https://www.ntu.edu.sg/news/detail/near-invisible-ultrathin-...
I'd personally prefer a larger frame with mat. Most nice looking art is framed this way.
This one has a mat ($1,700):
https://inkposter.com/products/inkposter-affresco-31-5
Here's the display alone, more cheaper ($650):
https://www.cdw.com/product/samsung-em32dx-emdx-series-32-cl...
> $1,299.00
Whoa, no thanks. I _love_ e-ink and as I was reading I was bracing myself for $300-400, 3-4x that doesn't work for me. I get it's large, I know that large e-ink (even b/w) are not cheap but $1.3K is too rich for my blood.
I was going to buy it as just a nice all-in-one I could flash my own firmware on but not at that price. I guess I'll keep playing with my 7" e-ink screens run by ESP32's or BTLE boards.
I've been eyeing the TRMNL X for a while, but I heard the launch was very unreliable. Has anyone here had any experience with it?
I made a 13 inch version myself for about $300, battery powered, esp32
So those complaining about price, it’s not bad tbh
What screen did you use?
Waveshare https://www.waveshare.com/13.3inch-e-paper-hat-plus-e.htm
Inky Impression has been popular lately. It's ~$275 on its own though. I am making a bird frame running fugleramme[0] and to purchase all of the materials (including RaspberryPi 5, power, frame, etc.) it's about $400 total.
0: https://github.com/arnegiacomo/fugleramme
Haven‘t tried it out yet, but isn‘t the Samsung em32dx an alternative?
It's a bit expensive, at $1,299.
Switchbot Frame [1] is on sale for ~1100, I don't think you're going to find much in a large eInk display like that for less. This looks a lot better and the software sounds better (as a switchbot owner)
[1] https://us.switch-bot.com/products/switchbot-ai-art-frame-2
I think it's considered cheap in it's class. It looks like a similarly sized InkPoster is 1,700. BLOOMIN8 has a 28.5" one that's on pre-order for $2,200.
Yeah the cheapest spectra 6 31.5” product I can find that is not just the bare panel is the Samsung emdx around $950. $1200 with a nice frame and better software support is reasonable to me.
seems like the class is not viable for now.
Yeah, the tinkerer in me would really love to get one but even at this comparably decent price point it's... steep.
Literally 2.5-3x the cost of a similarly sized 4K monitor + handmade frame.
I know e-ink is special, but man, the target market at the current pricing must be people with >100K in the bank or something.
Hope to see some competitors pop up with a better value play.
It's actually less than I would have expected for a small batch device. Samsung's EM32DX, which uses the same type and size of panel, is ~$1500 MSRP.
yeah, idk why they don't do a smaller version, e.g. spectra6 13.3" panel retail price is around 140USD
haven't seen $140 for 13.3” spectra 6, can you share a link? we do already support those models (firmware + core app + oss servers) however, and i don’t like competition.
https://www.seeedstudio.com/13-3inch-Six-Color-eInk-ePaper-D...
That is just the raw panel, no driver circuitry, no processing unit, no wifi or bluetooth. It's not really comparable to a finished product.
Yea that would be this for $300
https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html
I actually ordered their 3.97" reTerminal Sticky (monochrome) for 50 bucks last week. Excited to mess with it, I've never had an ePaper anything.
Yep, that's more like it!
Disclaimer: I'm CEO of Pimoroni and we make similar products in the UK: https://shop.pimoroni.com/products/inky-impression?variant=5...
$1,199* for a bit longer ;)
94 dpi
Why does the "transparent supply chain" list "Overseas" instead of the actual place of origin? The US-sourced parts go as far as saying the city for some entries. It just looks like a ridiculous avoidance of saying China.
I really dislike the muted colors, soft spoken, quiet music, product videos that seem to be everywhere, talking about how "different" they are. Showing someone hand-carving into a piece of wood, talking about "made in the USA", like some third-generation craftsman with a beard and a cap. It all feels like artisanal firewood. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI
I'm sure it's a high quality product, but given that "hacking" a random screen is just a Claude prompt these days, I think it's a hard sale. I think most consumers don't really care about the advantages of eInk versus a cheap display.
https://wesbos.com/hacking-smart-photo-frames
This would be a heck of a lot more interesting if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller instead of just putting up with eink's glacial pace of, well, everything (development, improvement, actual image refresh on the panel). There's so much possible with the multipigment screens that's yet to be unlocked with better driver hardware and software.
See https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider/blob/main/README.md#fas... for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7), or https://www.eniacelec.com/pages/tickey for an actual recent product that's pushing 48 native colors on a spectra 6 panel.
For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.
> if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller
What do you specifically mean? Are you Modos?
> for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7)
"Though to be honest I hacked the right one a bit to display 512 colors opposed to the stock 7 colors".
There's only 4 pigments, CMYK in the panel. Dithering is "512 colors"?
> eink's cruddy driverware
What do you specifically mean?
I see a few comments mentioning the price is 1.2k. But I saw $1,299 which is basically 1.3k, even more expensive!
Seems it doesn't support wifi or any internet connectivity (zero mention of any of these on any of the sites), which makes it essentially useless. Tough for the price.
What’s fps on this?
Everyone's making the same mistake here... eInk and ePaper are not necessarily the same thing. eInk is a type of ePaper. eInk is a brand.
Looked interesting, until I saw that you had to pay an extra $20 for unlocking developer mode. At the $1300 price point, nickel-and-diming me for $20 was such a completely unneeded snap in the face, that i closed the purchase tab. Good luck I guess, but i will not be a customer, out of principle.
appreciate the feedback. our perspective is we bend over backwards for the dev community. priority support, 1:1 team chats in our dev-only Discord, manual plugin reviews by hand prior to publication, etc. but if you choose to self host, unnecessary.
Cheap ereaders such as xteink were made popular partly due to the unlocked firmware and custom roms for them. I guess this is a completely different target, but I would think double about it, you just need some guy with too much time and an llm agent to make something that goes popular on YouTube/reddit (...), but for 20$ he might not even want to try it
100s of Xteink readers are hooked up to TRMNL. next step there is being able to sideload the ereader + dashboard binaries.
I think the $20 is a reasonable filter for access to the dev team's energy and time, especially given the alternative of a vastly more expensive moderation and review burden if the floodgates were left open to everyone. HN won't much like it, but that's a normal bias in our community, so don't let us sway you by emotions alone.
So why not a $0 "unlock anything you wish but no support, RTFM || GTFO" option?
Better option is to just provide the dev support for all devs that need something for this device and have it included in the large price. The price splitting makes sense when you have $100 device, but not for $1000+ device.
> Local hosting is also available and firmware is open source.
Yes i saw this and found this to be 100% in conflict with "pay to unlock". But when in doubt, I assume the interpretation that leaves me more screwed.
$2,000 ! zomg, I wish. I am not this rich haha.
I’m disappointed it’s missing adware and spyware.
What’s the point of an art frame if it doesn’t scan and profile your network to sell ads?
FWIW, you can get a much cheaper/smaller version here that uses the exact same display technology (Spectra 6):
https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html
Also, apparently Samsung's version uses the same Spectra 6 panel as well:
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1963755-REG/samsung_e...
I would buy one at $1200 if the colors look good/rich in person and if you can change for a different frame. I have a feeling I'm going to be disappointed though - most of the pictures make it look like it has a bit of a washed out appearance.
At 31.5” and 1440p resolution this display has a PPI of 94. So it’s probably best viewed from a distance. I’m waiting for my 13” version (~150 PPI) to see if it makes sense to go bigger.
For something hanging on a wall, I'd think a viewing distance of several feet would be entirely normal.
The tl;dr should include the price. That is the one thing I click on the page looking for.
LLM slop in user-facing UI. "Stays on screen until another screen's time comes." :/
The promo video is also an AI slop script. It's always jarring hearing a person speak Claudish.
only wooden frame is made in the US
the display itself is made in China using Chinese technologies
"we spend our time looking at screens" invents another screen
To all those decrying that this device is USD 1200 - you should look at the Samsung EM32DX and Samsung EM32DX-A displays. They are likely the same panel in a (flimsy) digital signage frame, and the EM32DX has gone for EUR 500 recently. Both devices started at EUR 1200 as well, so I guess that is just the cost for the eInk panels.
https://geizhals.de/?in=&fs=samsung%20em32dx
Likely, they will also show up on eBay soon.
I hate this childish, deliberate, lower-case style even more than reading something an LLM has written. Unbelievable that this is on a corporate blog.
Completely agreed. There's a place for that style in discord messages and texts, but for proper communication it comes off as childish and insincere.
In the same vein is using the word "corporate" imagining that it conveys some meaning other than the user not understanding that one person corporations are a thing.
It conveys that the presentation of a business is different than a person, if the person is at all professional and adult. The number of employees is irrelevant.
A single person still wears different clothes and speaks with different language when acting as or on behalf of a business, than when at home in their pajamas passing a bong with their friends.
A business, like anyone, can certainly decide that it wants to portray this exact crafted image intentionally (rather than as the result of being dipshits) but equally potential cutomers or vendors can percieve that image however they want and make whatever judgements and conclusions about the business operators they want from it.
Anyway the single-personhood has no bearing. You're accusing someone of something only you did.
You've argued against the straw man you've created that "corporate" and "business" are synonyms - the same as the original commenter. Just say "business" if that's what is meant instead of tarting it up in some imagined way by writing "corporate". Unless you actually wouldn't object to the presentation style if the business was, instead, a partnership.
16:9 no thanks.