Windows 11 Is Collecting Data on Which Coding Agents and Developer Tools You Use (xusheng.dev)

343 points by cwaffles 5 hours ago

208 comments:

by s_dev 4 hours ago

Just as AI has advanced massively in the past two years, I think a lot of gamers would be shocked at how viable Linux is as a genuine gaming platform in 2026. I already have plans to switch from Windows to Linux, I even have Linux running from an external drive to play with it.

The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.

by SOLAR_FIELDS 3 hours ago

Praise Gabe. No seriously, you would not be saying this in 2026 had it not been for a singular person named Gabe Newell. Valve’s Proton initiative almost single handedly brought us this. I don’t use Steam, or really any Valve products or games, just as some observing third party it’s really hard to say that this would have happened had Valve not done the whole Proton thing

by Gigachad 2 hours ago

Before Valve gaming on Linux was limited to Super Tux Kart and a small number of ported games. Once steam came to Linux around 2013 you had a selection of indie games mostly Unity stuff that could export to Linux for free. But still almost all major games did not work.

Proton was the turning point where you went from specifically looking for Linux games to just assuming everything works.

by Scaevolus an hour ago

Wine existed long before Valve poured money into it. It was nowhere near as reliable before DXVK existed, but you could play many commercial Windows games well-- you just couldn't expect nearly universal support.

by 0x696C6961 an hour ago

Wine was already an excellent project before valve came into the picture.

> ... you could play many commercial Windows games well

But this is just not true.

by goldie_wilson an hour ago

I guess it depends on your definition of "play". I got many commercial games running after hours of tweaking using Wine. Many had graphics errors and performance issues but one could ~technically~ play them.

by matheusmoreira 2 hours ago

Thank you, Gaben. Happy customer for 21 years.

by esperent 3 hours ago

CEO worship is weird and exhausting.

This was the work of hundreds of people. My understanding is that the majority of it wasn't even done by Valve (they are not Linux experts after all) but rather commissioned by them and the actual work done by other companies.

All those experts deserve recognition, not just the billionaire at the top who said "let it be so".

by yoyohello13 2 hours ago

Normally I’d agree with you. But Valve is a unique org that without Gabe would not be what it is. He made many pro-consumer anti-profit decisions. It’s worth a bit of praise.

by mdavidn an hour ago

I love Proton and use SteamOS daily, but I wouldn’t characterize the projects as “anti-profit.” I think Gabe correctly recognized the Windows monopoly and Microsoft Store as threats to his business. Microsoft wanted to recreate Apple’s App Store on their platform and take 30%.

by Alive-in-2025 an hour ago

They are threats to, his business, but also threats to us owning the software we use, to having freedom to pick a hardware platform. We won't benefit as Microsoft and the hardware companies try harder and harder to lock down the computer platform.

Gate is good for the world! That doesn't mean we have to see him as some kind of perfect person. He's doing good things for the world. Let's keep supporting him.

by NewJazz an hour ago

Gabe can win and we can win at the same time. So I agree, his actions are not necessarily anti-profit (whether in intention or reality).

by mrheosuper 2 hours ago

He is also the one decided you cant play multiple purchased games at the same time.

There is no technical limitation for this, only profit purpose.

by somenameforme a minute ago

What are you talking about? You absolutely can. I just checked to see if it was some new thing by opening a bunch of games at once, nope - no problems at all.

by usefulcat 2 hours ago

It’s like the mirror opposite of “damning with faint praise”. I wonder if there’s a name for that? Praising with faint criticism?

by Loudergood 2 hours ago

Actually family sharing opens that back up.

by yoyohello13 2 hours ago

Proton + Easy Refunds is what I care about.

Also, I thought Steam Family sharing allowed simultaneous play from shared libraries.

by mrheosuper 30 minutes ago

Not really work because you can only log in 1 account at same time on 1 computer.

by bigyabai 2 hours ago

I'm barely capable of playing one game at a time, so it works out great for me.

by bshaughn 3 hours ago

The praise here is the opposite of the broader CEO worship you speak of. People love Gabe because he's hell bent on making something good for consumers (rather than being hell bent on taking consumers money)

by jmb99 an hour ago

As long as you ignore gambling.

by Brian_K_White 2 hours ago

So is meaningless dismissal.

Refute the point by showing how it's not true.

Wine already existed, and there were already a few companies trying to add polish to it, and there were already "living room" ui's, all before Valve, yet it is still true that the only reason it went from theory to reality is because Valve dug in and hauled it over the line, and the only reason Valve did that was because Gabe simply decided it was their way around MS and Sony and everyone else.

The comment gives credit to someone for doing something valuable. That is not worship. A worshipper might also do that, but so would a reasonable human.

I recognize countless people for countless things that I appreciate without worshipping any of them.

by stockresearcher 2 hours ago

The company doing a large portion of the work posts on HN Who’s Hiring frequently. It makes me wonder if it’s impossible to get a job there, they aren’t actually hiring, or if turnover is insane.

by sam345 3 hours ago

I have seen many CEOs wreck companies. Believe it or not CEOs actually do make a difference. Without good ones your company will go nowhere and with bad one they get destroyed. They set the direction. So yes I do think he deserves credit. Don't understand the billionaire hatred.

by mhh__ 2 hours ago

The Napoleonic wars were fought by millions and yet they're named after Napoleon for some reason

by bigyabai 3 hours ago

CEO worship is weird when they're anti-philanthropy, or invest in enshittifying products.

But when CEOs make the right decision, selflessly, why can't we celebrate it? The work Valve sponsored created competitive pressure that Windows never had before. Microsoft cannot rest on the laurels of DirectX anymore, which has been a concern from the entire GPU industry since the Xbox came out.

Yes, CodeWeavers and Wine deserve applause. They both accept financial contributions if you'd like to go further than just lip service, but something tells me you don't have the fuck-you money that Gabe lined his pockets with.

by GeekyBear an hour ago

Gabe didn't invent Wine, he just forked it.

Although they did finally get around to sponsoring some of the work.

by sph 26 minutes ago

It’s not a fork, AFAIK it’s a set of ‘experimental’ patches on top of Wine, but it’s work that eventually gets merged into the project when/if accepted by its maintainers.

by eastof 4 hours ago

I'm an avid gamer, fully made he switch earlier this year to CachyOS. Dota 2 is my main game, I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows. I play other games like PEAK, Risk of Rain 2, and Enshrouded no problem with my friends. I have been enjoying STALKER 2 on Linux as well, runs just fine.

The biggest barrier is kernel anti cheat, so no Call of Duty, Battlefield, etc. Luckily my friends don't play those AAA multiplayer games, protondb is a good resource to check which games can't run due to their anti cheat.

by Wowfunhappy 3 hours ago

> I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows.

How is this actually possible? Wine is always going to add at least a little overhead because it has to translate system calls and such, right? And, well, I know Linux GPU drivers have improved a lot, but are they really better than the Windows drivers now?

by unrented7977 3 hours ago

Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support. Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.

As for faster, it's not that Linux does anything special to improve speeds, Windows is just genuinely that bad. Windows on its own consumes more resources than pretty much any Linux distro which means there's more compute for your game.

Again counter-intuitive: compatibility is better with Linux. I have some old games that won't play on modern Windows but work flawlessly under Linux.

There really is no good reason to use Windows other than being locked into Adobe software or whatever. Linux is just better in pretty much every sense.

by Wowfunhappy 2 hours ago

> Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support.

Isn't Valve's own recommendation to target Windows and let Proton handle Linux compatibility?

> Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.

I know, but Proton is just Valve's branch of Wine.

by Gigachad 2 hours ago

I don’t think this is actually true. If anything native linux games have become less common after proton.

Native Linux builds used to have their own bugs like dynamically linked libraries which would go missing over time. While running a windows build in proton means any issue can be solved by the community rather than begging the publisher.

by jack_pp 2 hours ago

Or if you're like me and your laptop/ GPU isn't yet supported by Linux well enough.

by esperent 3 hours ago

> Like, Wine does have to translate system calls and such, so it's always going to add some overhead, right?

Yes, of course. The key to understanding it is that this is still less overhead than Windows adds.

by jordand 3 hours ago

Windows 11 has a lot of overhead with CPU and RAM from my experience (also compared to Windows 10). A minimal Arch/CachyOS setup is surprisingly light, especially for older hardware

by NathanielK 3 hours ago

Some games are using directx to vulkan layers where vulkan drivers are better than directly using old directx. Hard to say for sure though.

by plantain 2 hours ago

Often because it's not a complete reimplementation and some functionality is skipped/silently missing.

by Creamsicle47 3 hours ago

Counter-Strike

by Waterluvian 3 hours ago

Linux gaming was basically a hobby for so long until the muscle at Valve really brought things along. The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person. But Valve is also really bringing that along, too.

by tombert 12 minutes ago

My wife's gaming PC is NixOS with KDE and she doesn't seem to have a lot of issue with it. She's not really a computer person and hasn't had too much trouble navigating modern KDE at all, though granted she does have me for tech support if necessary.

I really don't think modern Linux is "nerd UI" anymore, at least KDE and Cinnamon are pretty approachable for non-software people.

by breakwaterlabs 2 hours ago

Modern KDE (6.x) with OnlyOffice and Brave/firefox is a dramatically better experience for the 99% than Windows 11.

It’s incredible that the comparison of Windows 7 vs 2009’s Linux still remains the measure by which people judge the current status quo.

Seriously go onto either and try to:

- Edit a docx file (Windows: prepare for licensing fun)

- Set your audio output to use a Sonos or homepod (KDE: 2 clicks; Windows: impossible)

- Edit a PDF file (Windows: abandon all hope)

It’s rather analogous to trying to use a smart TV’s native interface vs an AppleTV. I guess if you want a slow, un-ergonomic, ad-ridden, half-baked experience…?

by fidotron 3 hours ago

KDE is now better than both Windows and Mac OS.

The frog has been boiled so much on those desktops people don't see how much they suck now.

by Wowfunhappy 3 hours ago

> The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person.

But also, most PC gamers are computer people, maybe not to quite the same extent as the average HN reader but certainly much more than the average person. Non-computer people play games on consoles.

by weakened_malloc 3 hours ago

>But also, most PC gamers are computer people

I think you'd be shocked at how untrue this is. Most people under like, 30, who game on PC barely even understand folder structure. They just prefer PC either because of the games it offers (counter strike, for example) or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.

by mrbungie 3 hours ago

If that's the case they could just use Bazzite/SteamOS and call it a day, CS runs native on Linux.

Linux's real "issue" with gaming is that it doesn't support most non-Valve AAA multiplayer titles namely COD, Battlefield, Marvel Rivals, Overwatch, LoL, Valorant, among others.

by weakened_malloc 2 hours ago

Linux's issue is that its not user friendly. Has it become much, much more user friendly over the years? Absolutely! But in that same period of time Windows has only been more and more dumbed down.

Put yourself in the shoes of an iPad kid born in the mid 2000s. All they know is an app store and maybe a downloads folder (that isnt called a folder). They know windows, maybe they use it at their part time job or something, so they get a PC and install windows. Steam is the app store.

Lots of them genuinely have no idea about downloading random .exe files to install, file structure in a computer, or even getting drivers directly from the hardware manufacturer's website.

From that point of view, Linux, however simple, is extremely complex. The other compounding factor is that these younger people typically focus on f2p, GAAS type games. Warzone, Fortnite, and so on. All games that wont work on linux. So the proportion of a younger cohort playing games that just wont work on linux is higher than say, you or me.

by jack_pp 2 hours ago

Can't play faceit on Linux because of the anti cheat

by Wowfunhappy 2 hours ago

> or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.

I mean, you're saying they know what FPS means, that's kind of a big deal.

I'd assume most also have some idea of what antialasing is, what VRAM is, and stuff like that. Because otherwise... I don't understand how you do anything? Are people just buying prebuilt PC's from Dell and using the default graphical settings?

by weakened_malloc 2 hours ago

I get most of my knowledge of this from both having younger family members and having gone back to uni, so speaking to uni age people whilst feeling like a boomer myself.

They've got no idea what AA is, but follow the rule of thumb that higher number = better. FPS matters as much as they notice the game feels better, but if you press them on their monitor refresh rate, they would have no idea.

They'll buy pre-built custom PCs from PC builders, or in my case, get a family member (me) to build it given a particular budget. Download steam, then hit install. Sometimes they'll change the graphics settings ingame but that typically comes to the pre-set settings profiles (low/med/high/ultra etc).

by Gigachad 2 hours ago

This was true pre 2015 but it’s very much untrue today. Xbox died off PS5 has stagnated, PC gaming has been constantly growing and mobile has exploded.

By the numbers the average gamer plays on a phone.

by HanShotFirst 2 hours ago

I agree, but LLMs have made the pain points MUCH easier to navigate over the past few years.

by k0morebi 3 hours ago

What is terrible about Linux ui? I've used it for so long I can't step outside of and be objective. Hard to believe it's worse than win 11 or golden gate for any of the major desktop environments (only used kde for a while, though)

by the__alchemist 3 hours ago

Some pain points. (It's tough for me too as I'm familiar and comfortable with it)

  - Reliance on terminal
  - Sudo system feels designed for servers and muti-user IT systems; is friction for PC use
  - Software installation can be inconsistent and/or use CLI. Depends on the software; it's possible to make easy-install linux software, but some vendors make it complicated or require compiling from source for reasons I don't understand.
by dijit 2 hours ago

Desktop linux largely uses polkit and elevation dialogues, not sudo.

What have you needed to do with terminal? KDE (kubuntu etc) largely shouldn't, it's an option for power users, it shouldn't be something you are forced to interact with: similar to cmd or the windows registry... it exists but it's not like you are expected to interact with it.

I also haven't compiled software for myself in about a decade. But of course you are beholden to the package maintainers.

by Washuu 36 minutes ago

I recently have been experimenting with Fedora.

Every piece of software(1Password, my own, and others) that I wanted to install has required me to paste an incantation into the command line to install it. It is incredibly unfriendly to less technically inclined users.

It should be:

Download RPM package ->

Double click RPM package ->

Approved access elevation prompt ->

Done!

Instead it fails completely by either trying to open the package like an archive or opening it in Discover to show the package information with no option to install it.

by dijit 20 minutes ago

Ideally you open “software centre” and there is a 1password you can just click “install” on, in fact: that is how it works. No need to use a web browser at all.

You’re applying Windows thinking to another OS. Maybe we should make dummy installers that are just links to package managers for refugees; you’d have the same problem going to a Mac, its only windows software that forces every application to have its own update lifecycle system in its own process.

by jack_pp 2 hours ago

All those are actually not that painful now that we have LLMs. Any config I need done I just ask DeepSeek to do it

by II2II 3 hours ago

The Linux UI isn't terrible. It sucks for macOS and Windows users simply because they have to invest time into learning it. For non-computer people, they don't want to deal with change. For computer people, they don't want to discard the years they have invested into developing workflows. All of the laundry lists of bad UI choices in Linux are just that. If a Linux user were to do the same, the lists would be just as long.

There are other places where Linux is weak, particularly in application support. Not everyone is a developer or a gamer.

by Gigachad 2 hours ago

One thing I observed installing Ubuntu on one of my parents computers is they just never updated it. Normal users never update things and expect the computer to update itself.

This is almost incompatible with the average Linux user who froths with rage if you even suggest the option of automatic updates.

by lunar_rover 2 hours ago

The foundation is unsuitable for non embedded/server environments. Everyone uses management tools so they can avoid maintaining FHS which is unsurprisingly one the first things Apple thrown out when transitioning to Unix.

Wake me up when KDE learns how to align things and how to be feature rich instead of button rich. Windows 11 is so bad it's almost on the level of Linux.

by Kuraj 2 hours ago

> Wake me up when KDE learns how to align things.

While I agree, and I have other minor criticisms (icons everywhere!), it's been so good for me in other areas I'm willing these things slip. I appreciate it for being an environment that is mature, has familiar defaults (to me), is not too opinionated and generally just gets out of my way.

by dfxm12 an hour ago

People have been complaining about Windows ux for a while. It's so weird and ad-ridden today compared to where it was in 2010. Most Linux distros come with something people are familiar with and like, taking bits from Windows 7 or osx

by fasterik 4 hours ago

I was expecting to have a degraded gaming experience in general when I dropped Windows, but Steam/Proton is impressively good. It can actually beat Windows performance on load times for some games, since the translated Vulkan shaders are cached. I suspect the issue with multiplayer games isn't any technical limitation, but rather the anti-cheat systems not allowing it.

by accrual 3 hours ago

Yes, I switched to Fedora in January and have been playing all sorts of games on an RTX 4080 via Steam, Heroic Games (Epic Games alternative launcher), Modrinth, emulators, etc. The only one I haven't tried is GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.

Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles - pop open a shell, describe the problem, and a few moments later it's fixed up. I recommend maintaining a doc as one gets the new system setup so it can be easily reproduced and referenced later. Anytime I change a setting or install an app I find useful, it goes in the doc.

by drnick1 3 hours ago

> GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.

> Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles

I have successfully bypassed the anticheat of several games that refuse to run on Linux, notably Valve's own. It's possible, but Claude now refuses such tasks.

by sph 22 minutes ago

Which Valve own games refuse to run on Linux/Proton?

by skilning an hour ago

I switched ten months ago and I'll never go back.

by keithnz 3 hours ago

I swapped earlier this year to linux as my main. It plays most every game I play. The ones it doesn't are the ones that have certain kinds of anticheat (so mostly multiplayer). Things like dota2 have a native client and work great. However, it isn't seamless for windows games, I had all kinds of minor issues which all needed some kind of adjustment to settings. Luckily in the world of AI I can just my AI agent to diagnose and fix issues. I really like it. Linux is completely viable for most anything and hopefully with enough momentum we will see more people switching. Not that I'm anti microsoft, I still use it at work and have it set up really nicely for the things I do and it has a bit more "polish". I just think its just much better long term that the OS is open source and random marketing / executives can't hijack windows (or apple) OS to inject things people just hate.

by novok 3 hours ago

Ironically, the mouse curve on linux for Dota 2 (a direct port to linux AFAIK) is the just the right kind of wrong that I still need to play it on windows. I've even had agents try to reproduce with a mounted copy of windows on the same computer and it got closer, but still not enough. Did you solve it?

by broodbucket 2 hours ago

Out of curiosity have you tried forcing the Windows version through Proton on Linux and seeing if it's a problem there? I've had to do this with CS in the past due to native bugs, could be an option if keeping Windows around is a pain

by rdudek 2 hours ago

I've been using CachyOS now for almost a year and it has been a very stable gaming environment. Granted, I don't play the latest FPS games. Mostly just World of Warcraft, Anno, and Civ.

The only weird issue I have is some websites, specifically banks just refuse me from logging in and give me a generic error or access denied. I pull up the same site on my macbook and it works fine.

by trashface 44 minutes ago

Depends on the multiplayer, MMOs often work fine, that's all I play and no complaints

by Aozora7 2 hours ago

Any time I tried desktop linux, I haven't seen anything that would make me want to use it daily over windows, even ignoring software compatibility issues. Windows sucks, but it sucks in a familiar way I can easily deal with so I can ignore its existence and just run the software I actually care about.

by dijit 2 hours ago

"the devil you know" is indeed a painful disincentive to switching, the natural lock-in effect of inertia is enormous and often understated.

Coupled with some major AAA's not working, I understand why people are reluctant to switch. It's a bit of a chicken and egg problem.

That said, it is hugely viable now, so you have a choice: surrender yourself to data mining and an increasingly hostile platform, or take the plunge and try.

I'm super happy that this choice exists, Microsoft no longer has us by the balls.

by jameson 4 hours ago

Yes. Steam has really contributed well to gaming on linux

Just a few days ago, I wanted to run WoW on linux. It was as simple as adding custom game (.exe) to steam and running it with proton.

I always kept Windows as a dual boot just in case I needed to play games but I no longer do

by gmerc 4 hours ago

CachyOs runs many windows games faster than windows which is mad ;)

by ctmlr 2 hours ago

It's usually console ports that have issues, otherwise all the PC games run great even with competitive with anti cheat. Valve has been doing god's work, Gabe deserves all the yachts.

by Zambyte 2 hours ago

> Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.

Vanishingly few by volume. Popularity is unfortunately a different story, but still few.

by _carbyau_ 3 hours ago

NB: I know very little regards linux and have not fully thought/researched this properly.

Install minimal linux on the bare metal. Using a VM with GPU pass through. (proper term for that which escapes me...)

It seems like it'd offer many benefits but is there a reason why this is not the common approach?

by skizm 3 hours ago

It is genuinely so much better. The only major issue (imo) is new releases are rarely supported.

by bitmasher9 16 minutes ago

It’s far more common for a new release to have Linux support than not. This has been the case for years.

by verelo 3 hours ago

Soon as PUBG is on Linux, I can kill my windows pc. Cant wait.

by bretpiatt 3 hours ago

How much PUBG do you play, dual boot?

It'll let you have cleaner and optimized for PUBG only Windows then too.

by verelo 3 hours ago

This will sound hilarious, but I only have a windows PC for the purpose of PUBG. I have some friends who I've been playing with for almost a decade now, and some of them have moved a few timezones away, PUBG is the major way we get to connect on a regular basis so I've stuck with it. I really can't be bothered messing around with dual boot, the rest of my life is on my Mac. If I could just boot into linux and work/play I'd probably switch my life to linux again.

by stavros 4 hours ago

I dropped Windows a long time ago. I don't have any games that Proton won't play, even BG3 ran great. Linux is a first class gaming platform now.

by citizenkeen 2 hours ago

If Affinity came to Linux I’d probably quit Windows. It’ll never happen now that it’s just Canva, but I need a better emulation package than I’ve figured out.

by e4m2 2 hours ago

> It’ll never happen now that it’s just Canva

https://x.com/Affinity/status/2117276850795790442

by gverrilla 4 hours ago

Yes! And using local llm harnesses can greatly assist in configuration, troubleshooting and customization! I'm 100% on Linux (Arch) since february - no regrets.

by democracy 4 hours ago

ubuntu?

by rvz 3 hours ago

> The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.

The truth is if it can't play the 2026 AAA games on day 1, let alone games such as GTA 6 especially with multiplayer, then gamers won't even bother to switch or even touch Linux consoles such as the Steam Machine.

They even rather buy a supported console (Xbox or PS5) to play the game first just to wait for it to be on PC, which will be a year later.

By the time it reaches Linux or the Steam Machine, it would be roughly 3 years after.

by bitmasher9 13 minutes ago

The default now is to release simultaneously on Xbox/Playstation/PC, with PC including proton support.

by Gigachad 3 hours ago

Claude will have GTA6 running on Linux with better than console performance real fast.

by herf 7 minutes ago

Windows has been very slow to make a sandbox for AI agents - they launched MXC just a month ago (Oct 7) and Claude Code doesn't even support it yet. So we have people running un-sandboxed agents on Windows, or they use WSL instead. All of this to say, yes I hope they have some non-invasive telemetry to know what to prioritize, because the platform needs features like this pretty urgently.

by dead_hn_theory 4 hours ago

For anyone on the fence about switching from Windows to Linux: it takes about a week, if that, of adjusting. If most of what you do is on the Web already (and the services you use provide a Web-based client), you have nothing to lose but your chains.

Take your pick - Ubuntu, Fedora, someone else mentioned Mint. All fine choices, no wrong answers.

by wry_xy 44 minutes ago

As someone who daily drives all 3 major operating systems... I could never recommend Linux to someone without big caveats.

I wish I could. I wish it could do everything well. But it just doesn't.

If all you do is web, then use your phone or a tablet. Windows isn't the right choice for that either.

by devsda 15 minutes ago

> If all you do is web, then use your phone or a tablet.

Moving from windows device to a phone/table because it collects names of coding agents would be a perfect example of out of the frying pan to the fire, given the choice of OS we have for those.

If those caveats are not a big deal(depends on the person) compared to the privacy issues, linux is still a better option.

by cortesoft 3 hours ago

As someone who owns and operaters Linux, Windows, and Mac systems at home, this just isn't true for a lot of people.

I have to keep my gaming PC as Windows because I can't play Madden, EA FC, or PUBG on my Linux machines nor my Steam Deck (unless I install windows). They all require kernel level anti-cheats that are only supported on Windows.

You also can't play a ton of other very popular games (that I don't happen to play, but millions do) like Call of Duty, Fortnite, League of Legends, Battlefield, etc. Those games have millions of players.

And this is just for gaming. There are plenty of other bits of software that don't run on Linux, even with all of the amazing work that has gone into compatibility tools like WINE.

I am not saying that many people shouldn't explore moving to Linux from Windows, but I don't think it is helpful to say everyone can switch without at least mentioning any of the reasons people can't.

by phendrenad2 7 minutes ago

[delayed]

by boplicity 4 hours ago

Unfortunately, software developers haven't caught up, and many critical applications for some people just don't work well enough. For Linux to be viable for many people, they need to be able to just click on their application and for it to work. No fiddling involved. Even with fiddling, though, it's too easy to lose time and not come up with a solution.

This has to do with software developers not supporting it well enough; nothing's wrong with many of the distros.

by annzabelle 2 hours ago

I've been caught on considering switching from an M1 macbook pro to a framework linux laptop, but I'm not fully confident in whether linux is up to the "just works" state. I used to use linux on my laptop and desktop for a couple years, but when computers stopped being a hobby and started being a job, I didn't want to spend my evenings fiddling with driver issues.

At this point I don't use any computers much outside of work. I do most email and chat on my phone and have a reddit app that got the accessibility exemption and is ad/algorithm free. I pull out my laptop once a week or so and I am mostly just using chrome. I've considered switching to a tablet, but I have been thinking about going back to uni and I would need a laptop for that.

With how intermittently I'm even using a computer at all at this point, I don't want to have to be thinking about version updates every time I log in and it's nice to have something idiot-proof. I am comfortable with the terminal and have used linux in various contexts for a decade (though not on the desktop/laptop in the last 5 years), but maintaining my laptop is no longer a hobby.

by kibwen an hour ago

I can recommend System76 for Linux machines that just work. They have their own distro (Ubuntu/Debian-based) that's tested with the hardware they ship, I've never had a single need to fiddle with drivers or anything else. As a product line they're a little weird in that they seem to work with whatever hardware they can get their hands on from OEMs, so there's not much look-and-feel consistency from model to model and generation to generation, but I can attest that the current-gen Lemur Pro is excellent.

by Gigachad 3 hours ago

This is changing rapidly. I was stuck on MacOS because I needed Lightroom and DJ apps. Today there are open source alternatives popping up that are very close to closing the gap for me.

As well as Affinity announcing Linux support soon.

by boplicity 3 hours ago

I want to believe you, but this very closely echoes the "year of Linux" that's always been a year away...

by Gigachad 2 hours ago

The year of the Linux desktop is a meme because Linux desktop isn’t a fixed target where one day it’s suddenly viable. It’s a gradient where it becomes more viable for more people over time.

And I think AI boosting open source is a huge push towards making it viable.

by novok 3 hours ago

I've found agents have solved most of this because they can do the fiddling.

by thetallgeek an hour ago

Which do you think is the best distro which maintains compatibility with all/most windows key strokes? Most importantly - Win-E for explorer, alt-tab for switching windows, ctrl-tab for switching tabs within a window. If I switch my home PC to linux, I will still need windows at work and can't afford to have different key bindings

by ainka-ainka 30 minutes ago

Any distro with KDE would work in this scenario, because i had the same thought when i started with Linux. Kubuntu and Fedora's KDE spin are good options to get started.

For the shortcuts that don't exist or don't do what you want, you can trivially configure them. Example - ctrl+shift+esc doesn't bring up "task manager", but you can simply right click on KSystemMonitor in start menu and assign that shortcut.

by missmewiththatl 30 minutes ago

Use Debian, or if you're more security minded use Fedora.

by makeitdouble 2 hours ago

The main caveat would be to not care too much about hardware: if you're on a classic desktop or standard laptop setup it should be fine. Basically, if you could move to macos, you could move to linux as well.

If instead you're spending your life on a Surface Pro or a Z13, or some other alternative form factor, linux is probably not for you yet. It runs, but touch support and QOL for tablet mode is subpar at best.

by NSPG911 an hour ago

I agree with this. Touch support is quite awkward, stylus support is especially worse since stylus is considered an absolutely positioned mouse than a type of touch. I'm using a Lenovo Ideapad 5, and the main reason why I have yet to switch fully (I have CachyOS on an external SSD) is due to the pen support and also shitty OneNote support (I'm supposed to use a browser??)

by xyst 4 hours ago

hard mode: nixos

Then you will never go back to non-declarative system ever again

by ezst 2 hours ago

Not to diminish NixOS, but what good do you believe is in there for the normal folks, besides precious disk space wasted, "everything that touches software installation" becoming orders of magnitudes slower, and more cognitive overhead?

by _s_a_m_ 2 hours ago

yeah, i hear that since the 90s, no, just no.

by cheschire 4 hours ago
by Kodiack 4 hours ago

I like Linux Mint for basic use cases, but for anyone with more robust needs I'd recommend an alternative. Linux Mint still only uses X11, which means that a lot of reasonably common modern features such as HDR are unsupported.

by novafunc 12 minutes ago

Linux Mint 27 is scheduled for December and will offer a Wayland session. Though I believe Xorg is still the default.

by PcChip 4 hours ago

I’d recommend CachyOS - it’s far more up to date, especially with nvidia drivers and the kernel, and with the default limine bootloader you can easily load a snapshot in case an update breaks something

by pitched 4 hours ago

+1 for Cachy. Arch, even though its reputation opposes this, is very friendly for newcomers because it bypasses the normal version-mismatch issues that tend to creep into the normal distros. You get the latest good version of everything instead of the best version three months ago and hope everything else was compiled against that.

by drnick1 3 hours ago

Except that the Arch installation process is notoriously difficult/manual, even more so if you want a complete modern setup with disk encryption, secure boot, etc. The installer is supposed to help, but always crashed last time I tried to use it.

Of the big three base distros, Fedora is probably the best for gaming. It's straightforward to install relative to Arch, and the software packages are reasonably recent. Debian could also be viable on older hardware.

by w-ll 2 hours ago

ive been meaning to swap my main desktop (still windows) to steamos. are i dont game too much. at least AAA but i like to make stuff that needs gfx. is there an argument against steamos which i think is a fedora fork?

by drnick1 an hour ago

SteamOS is based on Arch, not Fedora. I think it's Bazzite that it's based on Fedora. SteamOS isn't designed to run on hardware other that Valve's IIRC, Bazzite is basically the generic hardware version of it.

by onemoresoop 4 hours ago

Windows 11 is probably collecting a lot more data and phoning it home.

by pseudosavant 2 hours ago

Serious question I have anytime people get upset about telemetry like this with Windows: why isn't there a similar level of outrage against Android, iOS, ChromeOS, Googlebook OS, and Mac?

The real outlier in all of this are Linux distros. Every other commercial OS is tracking a lot, but it seems like Windows is the only commercial OS people expect to not track you? There is no way Apple and Google don't know which apps people are using on their OSes too.

Google is the worst offender of this by far. They'll correlate data across every Google thing you do (every email, browser history, app usage, audio recordings, car driving habits, etc) and very effectively sell/manipulate you with ads based on that. Microsoft only wishes they were half as good at milking and monetizing tracking like Google.

by ByteOfWood 39 minutes ago

Because Windows was not always like this. It has gotten much more telemetry "features" over the years, on top of generally user hostile changes, which upsets people.

The other OSes have always given the user less freedom, except for Android, which people are similarly outraging about, and dealing with that problem through custom roms.

by ronsor 2 hours ago

That's easy, at least the first four:

Android and iOS: smartphones are surveillance devices anyway, and everyone expects it.

ChromeOS and Googlebook OS: the cloud is the selling point. Of course it sends all your data to Google.

Mac, I suppose, gets off the hook as long as the telemetry is branded as security support infrastructure.

by swozey 21 minutes ago

I needed to clear my 100gb gmail to stop paying $4.99/mo, I knew they wouldn't let me, but figured if Gemini is going to ask me every day to connect to my gmail, I'll see if it can categorize and clean up my 21GB left over of email.

Nope. Can't function against bulk mail. Can only function on small searches, etc. No "Gemini, clean up my spam." lol.

by Elseself 3 hours ago

Hell Microsoft is probably collecting data on what color my pee was this morning

by 4k93n2 28 minutes ago

  180024b10  wchar16 L"pee"...[0x7] = "#efef8f", 0
clippy: "hey! your pee is looking a bit dark this morning. try drinking a glass of water!"
by hahn-kev 2 hours ago

Probably not last Friday

by knollimar 4 hours ago

I pray for the day Linux gets real anti cheat and autodesk products run there

by giantg2 2 hours ago

Maybe use a free AutoDesk alternative. I refuse to pay for AutoDesk.

by none_to_remain 4 hours ago

Anti cheat needs to consist of competitive g*mers traveling somewhere for LAN play on clean equipment provided by whatever league

by GuB-42 3 hours ago

This is for high level competitive gamers, a small fraction of total gamers.

This is high profile because there is a lot of money involved, but even casual gamers don't want their fun to be ruined by cheaters. And they are definitely not going to travel and be provided equipment by the bronze league.

I don't know if it is still the case but "I play on console because I don't want to play with PC gamers, too many cheaters" was something I heard a few times, and not from competitive gamers.

by tandr 2 hours ago

I thought Autodesk used to have a "hardware key" option for verifying licensing - you plug usb key of sorts (was looooong time ago) and license check goes against that hd token thing-y? Or was it some other CAD product, but the idea is the same.

by misswaterfairy 3 hours ago

At least for AutoDesk products virtualisation might be viable with QEMU, that way you can dump Windows mostly but still keep it isolated in a VM until Wine catches up.

by drum55 3 hours ago

Fusion does not run at all outside of native windows, it relies a lot on hardware acceleration despite being some variation of a web app.

by luyu_wu 3 hours ago

Actually Fusion works great on Linux (https://codeberg.org/cryinkfly/Autodesk-Fusion-360-on-Linux).

I ran this daily back when I needed Fusion for work this summer.

by drnick1 3 hours ago

Is Wine/Proton not an option? People run all kinds of games on Linux with hardware acceleration.

by misswaterfairy an hour ago

For some it isn't. I prefer Solid Edge over AutoDesk Fusion/Inventor though Solid Edge isn't supported with Wine or Proton.

Solid Edge does work well in a VM on a 2020 MacBook Pro with a Windows guest, though.

Solid Edge does have a Community Edition, so it's easily possible to check if it works on a particular setup.

by sitzkrieg 4 hours ago

linux will never get any anti cheat worth mention, by design

by Kodiack 4 hours ago

Easy Anti-Cheat Linux v2 is coming along, with some distros working on support for it (e.g. CachyOS).

https://wiki.cachyos.org/configuration/easy_anti_cheat/

by luqtas 4 hours ago

amen. as justifying not using Linux because some proprietary shit game with anti-cheat from companies like EA or Tencent shouldn't ever be a consideration to migrate

by pitched 4 hours ago

Current anti-cheat is all broken now with AI tools. The only solution is game streaming, which would work on Linux.

by ctmlr 2 hours ago

I bet there could be a machine learning anti-cheat that can just detect subtle player inputs that are unnatural.

by JDups 29 minutes ago

There are, like Valve's VACnet. It's just not as good as other anti-cheats.

by strbean 4 hours ago

Damn, I never thought of that approach. There may be yet be hope for multiplayer shooters.

by etherlink 3 hours ago

No, because game streaming adds unnecessary latency, its exactly the opposite you want for multiplayer shooters.

by plantain 2 hours ago

Multiplayer shooters are totally ruined by hackers currently. >50% chance of encountering a hacker in Wardogs on a given game.

I can't see any other solution coming.

by ctmlr 2 hours ago

The idea of owing rent to the game lord just doesn't sit right with me, not to mention the latency. I would rather just play old games on moderated community servers.

by canelonesdeverd 4 hours ago

Is game streaming even viable in this economy? (i.e. with all computing resources going to AI). I think xbox even limited playtime recently.

Not that I'd want to stream my games, of course :-)

by bob1029 4 hours ago

It's not viable in this universe. We need FTL communication for streaming gaming to not suck ass.

by GuB-42 3 hours ago

If the server is located reasonably close to you (same country/state), you can expect a round trip latency of ~10ms, which is less than the latency of a top of the line competitive PC, and well under the limit of human perception for audio and visual feedback. So, viable in this universe.

In practice, there are a lot more variables, but under 40ms is achievable today with a good PC, a good connection, and a reasonably close server. That's good enough for all but the fastest games with competitive gameplay, and cloud gaming is generally considered a better experience than a low-end PC.

by sitzkrieg 2 hours ago

even 20ms of local latency rules out entire genres of games, no thanks

by pavo-etc 40 minutes ago

Get excited, clean room AutoCAD on Linux is happening.

https://github.com/storytold/cadcraft

by Zagitta 3 hours ago

I'm running fusion 360 on Cachyos so it's at least partially there :-)

by 1-6 2 hours ago

Autodesk's moat is gone.

by the8472 2 hours ago

anticheat -> signed kernels/attestation -> corporate-blessed linux builds -> eventually get the same diseases as W11.

So uh, maybe just stay on windows?

by uproarchat 4 hours ago

Hard no to kernel level anti cheat.

by sooraj_sj 28 minutes ago

nothing is protected , they always spy

by scotty79 30 minutes ago

Windows Defender was quarantining text config files from Codex so persistently that I considered disabling it permanently.

by nout 3 hours ago

When I get a new laptop/desktop I used to do dualboot with Linux where I still keep the original Windows around. Not anymore, I fully clean install just Linux. I don't really need Windows for anything anymore and if something would come up, you can always run windows in a VM on Linux. I still have a device with MacOs, but even with that one I'm switching to Omarchy as soon as they have good support (it's almost there).

by sitzkrieg 4 hours ago

add it to the list of millions of reasons ill never update from windows 10 LTSC. ive never ran into anything not working either. aside from msstore stuff, which is completely removed

by gerdesj 4 hours ago

I imagine its costing you a pretty penny, running an Enterprise LTSC edition of Win10 that is still supported in some way.

by sitzkrieg 2 hours ago

no, its free. why would i pay ms for support i dont need? lol. this is my personal machine, not my business terminal

by msla an hour ago

That's just the information we know Windows 11 collects. How much private information does Microsoft have access to because it's on a Windows system that can phone home?

by h4kunamata an hour ago

Home users have zero reasons to use Windows in 2026.

Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.

There are distros like Mint Cinnamon that are awesome. Based on Ubuntu but without all the mess from it with solid support and community. It has newer packages like Ubuntu but the security practices like Debian.

From internet to video editing, from writing docs to playing Steam games, it just works.

Office?? LibreOffice. You shouldn't be using Microsoft Office even on Windows.

LibreOffice is solid, 100% offline, free, and received massive donations during Microsoft drama on Friday.

The only downside is for folks who play Steam games with kernel anti-cheat, that is spyware anyway and you should not be playing such games to start with.

You can isolate Steam by installing its Flatpak version, even if you installed a game found to be compromised, Flatpak sandbox isolates it. Avoid installing the native DEB package which grants full access to the system files, if you get a game compromised that way, then yeah, you are screwed.

Windows is not different, if you have Steam running on your Windows PC and installed a compromised game, good luck haha

by janalsncm 11 minutes ago

> Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.

Someone who is just now switching from Microsoft because of their crappy UX probably isn’t choosing their operating system based on an ethical framework. They want a low-hassle OS, that’s all.

by yostrovs an hour ago

Much of what you say, like the fact that there are different distros and something called packages, makes an average person zone out and lose all interest. It sounds like you still have to think about the OS, whereas with Windows you do not

by h4kunamata 28 minutes ago

>It sounds like you still have to think about the OS, whereas with Windows you do not

So stick with Windows giving all of your data to Microsoft and ignore my comment :)

by xeeeeeeeeeeenu 3 hours ago

Does this data show up in Diagnostic Data Viewer?

by jon128 2 hours ago

This kind of invasiveness is why some companies have switched to professionally supported Linux based distros and run Microsoft Office desktop apps in VMs (in a way wholly transparent to the users) on those systems.

by xyst 4 hours ago

Been using NixOS and haven’t looked back

by pavo-etc 41 minutes ago

NixOS really is bliss especially with agents. There are so many classes of problems you just cannot experience.

by bitmasher9 9 minutes ago

It’s crazy how little of the Linux mindshare NixOS has for how incredibly well positioned it is for the next 5 years.

by tonymet 3 hours ago

Windows 11 discloses this, and provides toggles for Required & Optional Diagnostic data. It also includes an app for you to browse the event entries .

The disclosure on Optional Diagnostic Data is shown with the UI control and is clear that website & app activity will be tracked, and that it can be turned off to no ill effect on the system functionality or security.

by TheJoeMan 2 hours ago

The article claims the data is always recorded, and if and only if your diagnostic sharing is off, it won’t upload it. That does not feel like a truthful interpretation of the data privacy toggle by Microsoft. Also, once you “decide” to re-enable sharing (aka. accidentally enable after an update) is there a high likelihood it will upload all of this previously collected data?

by JoBrad 2 hours ago

It’s also something Enterprises are explicitly paying to understand: who is using agents, and what data are they allowing them access to.

by QuantumNoodle 2 minutes ago

Oof spying on how successful their competition is.

by AngryData an hour ago

I just had to spend another 30 minutes removing "defender" because it was sucking up such resources and causing stuttering in various applications at random times. I did the exact same thing a few days ago going through group policies, registry settings, etc. Did it again today, still didn't work. Tried to do it through powershell which failed. Eventually resorted to random github scripts, which half failed, but once I used enough versions of them I finally got a boot today that it didn't load upon. Also tried to disable a bunch of other stuff through O&O Shutup, many of which still didn't work or reverted because Windows is such a clusterfark.

Like I almost wish I had a virus to break it, maybe that is what finally broke it after all these random scripts. But atleast I got my system CPU usage down below 5% while idling and doing nothing, and I haven't yet noticed any random 50% CPU usage spikes again, but you know I did all this a year or so ago too so it is perhaps just a matter of time.

Microsoft needs to die.

by nelsonfigueroa 4 hours ago

I sometimes jokingly say "Windows is spyware", but perhaps it's not that far off...

by AngryData an hour ago

It isn't a joke any more. Could be a half joke on earlier versions, but find a Windows 10 machine and try and disable defender for example. Oh sure you can disable in all the settings, it is still running in the background using significant resources if you check task or resource manager. Do group policy and registry edits, both from within and outside Microsoft's directions to disable it, still running. Powershell commands? Still running. Even as a power user that has used Windows since 3.1, it was difficult to actually accomplish and required resorting to random github scripts and programs run multiple times before it stopped. And im willing to bet that is only temporary. Next time I notice a big system stutter I can almost guarantee when I check task manger it will be one of the half dozen "defender" programs that decided to magically reenable itself.

by joshAg 4 hours ago

it's been true since they added this sort of enhanced telemetry back in windows 10's early days. Such a shame that OSes have been monotonically getting worse since the high point in 2009

by dmoose 4 hours ago

https://https://csrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/malware

"A program that is inserted into a system, usually covertly, with the intent of compromising the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of the victim’s data, applications, or operating system or of otherwise annoying or disrupting the victim."

by dmoose 4 hours ago

I guess we do need to keep seeing things like this on the front page just in case there is anyone who is not aware of Microsoft's stellar reputation for putting user security and experience first, but then again it does get old that about all you can say is Microslop gonna Microslop.

by lesspassiveobse 4 hours ago

That's one way to get very skewed data. Determine programming tool use but only from the population that uses Windows with optional telemetry enabled.

by speed_spread 3 hours ago

It's just prefiltered. If you're smart enough to disable telemetry, you're not part of the market segment they're interested in.

by flaunf221 4 hours ago

Optional diagnostic data includes some data. Well, I opted out of it during first setup, so I'll be fine.

by minimaxa 4 hours ago

It's interesting how Silicon Valley/Redmond companies can "extract" data from their users but not use any of the data collected to actually improve or help their users with tasks in their systems...

As an example, pointed an LLM at my file/folder drive and it cleaned and organized every single file into folders, deleting all duplicates perfectly in the background without one issue, and also advised of 40 GB of old Docker tests which were not needed.

2026 still waiting for Windows to work this out.

by flaunf221 3 hours ago

If you trust LLM to clean up disk without your input, you could just format whole drive and save some tokens. Because whatever data it holds can't be important, otherwise you wouldn't ever trust it to system that can go off the rails at any point.

by unstatusthequo an hour ago

Hint: it’s not copilot!

by sys_64738 4 hours ago

Now it's not called Windows because of the boxes on the screen. It's called Windows as it's looking into your soul to suck the life from you.

by arandomhuman 4 hours ago

And in other news: "Flaming Pile of Shit Continues to Burn"

by TacticalCoder 5 hours ago

Microsoft acting unethically?

by mococa 4 hours ago

No shit sherlock! Every company now is doing the same.

by skeledrew 4 hours ago

People complain about Window$. And continue to use it. Funny.

by t-writescode 4 hours ago

“Hrrrrrm, you hate capitalism and yet you live inside it! Hrrrmmmm”

by 903543958568 3 hours ago

Yeah because socialists are too comfortable with their worthless NGO jobs to move to North Korea.

by AngryData an hour ago

What? North Korea is not socialist at all. Or do you also believe it is democratic because NK says so?

by arandomhuman 4 hours ago

If you think an operating system is a flaming piece of shit (because it is), you really should stop using it. Windows isn't as pervasive as capitalism, it's just a shitty piece of software/software ecosystem one can stop using on their personal machines.

by t-writescode 2 hours ago

They can stop using it unless they can’t. There are still a few situations and a few pieces of hardware or software that don’t really have other options that don’t cost considerable amounts of money.

by shiwng 5 hours ago

This popping out after the latest bug isn't as surprising.

by dwm 5 hours ago

No it's not, I run Debian.

by christophilus 5 hours ago

I was going to say, “Not unless they backdoored Fedora.”

by embedding-shape 4 hours ago

https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/powershell-is-open-so... (2016)

Fun fact, PowerShell by default collect telemetry from its users, because why not, the more data the merrier? https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/module/microsof...

I'm guessing that's why "Microsoft loves Linux" yet Microsoft refuses to ship their software via the distributions repositories themselves, as probably this "send telemetry by default" stuff wouldn't fly and it'd cause drama.

by j3th9n 5 hours ago

And how is this news? This is to be fully expected already for a long time.

by sys_64738 4 hours ago

In case you forget.

Data from: Hacker News, provided by Hacker News (unofficial) API