Can Universities Survive? AI vs. Higher Education [audio] (ppfideas.com)

20 points by frereubu 4 hours ago

9 comments:

by chriskanan 2 minutes ago

I wrote an article about this a year ago: https://syntheticminds.substack.com/p/universities-must-embr...

But as a professor, enrollments are way down. In general, this was expected but not prepared for just due to the "demographic cliff" due to people having fewer children in the USA. I think university leadership had an aspirational hope that foreign enrollment would fill that gap, but instead foreign applicants have gone way down (and this was starting to happen even before the Trump administration accelerated it).

Universities are very slow moving and most professors, even in computer science, haven't really been using agents. Even as an AI professor, it is _so_ hard to keep up with the pace of change. I'd say my opinions are more dire now, than I express in that article I wrote a year ago.

by figers an hour ago

Ronny Chieng Commencement speech clip

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfdEs7VhvaX/

by yepyoukno 4 hours ago

Let us focus on the transformation of individuals into competent capable and responsible persons.

Universities have an opportunity to reinvent.

The mind that there must be a currency conversion for every virtue is a product of successful western consumertopia.

When we learn to live for ourselves rather than the measure of our projected whole we will learn in entirely new and more gratifying ways.

by frereubu 2 hours ago

I think you would enjoy the linked podcast. They cover a lot of this. There's also this episode in the same series that advocates for the role of universities in developing rounded people as a whole not just degree factories: https://www.ppfideas.com/episodes/can-universities-survive-f... Some enjoyable advocacy for English literature degrees given that the current UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham studied English at Cambridge.

by epolanski an hour ago

> Universities have an opportunity to reinvent.

Universities have always been about the growth of the individual and intellectual community.

It's only in the last 3 decades that the attention shifted on creating cogs that match the economic system.

Even on this very board you see endless comments about their curriculum not fitting whatever was the state of some industry at the time.

by scottLobster an hour ago

Please, the highest paid university faculty are coaches, and many prestigious private institutions (i.e. Harvard) have endowments so large they're essentially tax-advantaged hedge funds that double as finishing schools for the well-connected.

A university truly devoted to the growth of the individual and intellectual community is a pet project of the wealthy or bankrupt.

by HWR_14 39 minutes ago

> the highest paid university faculty are coaches, and many prestigious private institutions (i.e. Harvard)

The highest paid Harvard employee in a non-administrative role is a CS professor, making somewhere between 5x and 8x what the head coach makes.

by scottLobster 23 minutes ago

Meanwhile the head coach of Duke University Men's Basketball makes more than the University President.

And if you went to Harvard and misread my statement so badly, it's further indication that education isn't the top priority.

by gosub100 an hour ago

And get the prestigious-journal rat race cancelled too (publish or perish). Strictly focus on advancing their field of study.

I get the complaints about academic decline in students. But they're doing it to avoid poverty. I think that's a more noble cause than the research tier that chases grant money. They already have a huge cash flow from tuition. If the administration steals it for a new dorm tower and athletic center every 5 years, that's a separate problem.

Data from: Hacker News, provided by Hacker News (unofficial) API